movies are more educational than books

Search Please fill out this field.
Manage Your Subscription
Give a Gift Subscription
BHG Archives
Newsletters
Sweepstakes

Book vs. Movie: A Survey Settles the Debate Over Which Is Better

The results also reveal the most-watched film adaptation.

As a child, reading was one of my favorite activities, and it still is to this day. I've always loved immersing myself in the pages of a novel, entirely captivated by fictional characters and their stories. One part of the experience that almost always left me disappointed, however, was when one of my beloved books became a movie. And according to a recent survey, I'm not the only person who is let down by book adaptations.

SuperSummary , an online resource that provides study guides for fiction and nonfiction books, wanted to know the answer to a burning question: Book or movie? The company asked 2,030 people, ages 23 to 62, to answer questions about books that had been turned into movies or TV shows.

The results were fairly close. Overall, 34% of people enjoyed the book, compared to 27% who preferred the movie. Although 82% of those surveyed agreed that "screen adaptations help books come to life," 46% of people argued that film adaptations "would never be as good as the book." Almost 25% declared that movies even ruined the original book. The top three books that people preferred over the films were: The Da Vinci Code with 53.9%, The Chronicles of Narnia series with 52%, and the Fifty Shades trilogy with 47.3%.

The top reasons for not approving the film adaptation weren't surprising. Nearly 32% said that the movie was too different than the book, 13.4% of people said the film lacked key details, and a little more than 10% of those surveyed didn't like the approximate two-hour movie time limit.

Although respondents were divided on whether they prefer reading vs. watching, they were more aligned with the most-watched adaptation. Forrest Gump took home the top spot, with 76.9% of people saying they've seen it. However, only 5.6% of people said they enjoyed the book. Following was the Jurassic Park series with 74.8%, Charlie and the Chocolate Factory with 73.7%, and the Harry Potter series with 70.1%.

Perhaps the slight preference of the book over the movie is related to libraries being a little more popular than movie theaters . I completely understand why people might prefer watching a live, condensed version of a story on the big screen, but to me, there are few simpler pleasures than getting lost in the pages of a good book.

Books Vs Movies: Which Is Better? The Debate Settled!

Last Updated on August 18, 2023 by Louisa

Books and movies are two of the most popular forms of entertainment, but which is better? This age-old debate of books vs movies has been causing a stir for decades, so I’ve decided it’s time to settle the score once and for all.

While both offer unique ways to experience stories, there are pros and cons for each. When determining which is better, reading books or watching movies, the answer really is determined by a number of factors.

If you ask any reader, they will of course tell you all the reasons why books are better than movies, but if you ask a movie buff, you will receive a strong counter-argument for why movies are better.

In this guide, I’ve listed the reasons why you would want to choose a book over a movie, or a movie over a book, and in doing so, settle the debate once and for all.

To be clear, in this guide, we are concentrating on books that have been adapted into movies.

Books vs Movies Pros and Cons

If you need a quick summary of whether reading books or watching movies is better, then check out the below table which summarizes the points in this article.

Keep reading for a detailed analysis of reading books vs watching movies.

Pros of reading books over movies

There is more depth to a book, scenes are described in more detail, and have more plot-setting scenes.
A book allows the reader to use their imagination.
Readers follow the plot as it was intended by the author.

Cons of reading books over movies

Books take a long time to read, sometimes several days.
Some books can drag in the middle.
Dialogues can sometimes be unrealistic in books but come to life on the big screen.

Pros of watching movies over reading books

Movies are quicker than books.
You can watch a movie with a friend, but you can’t read a book with someone else.
You don’t have to concentrate on a movie and there is less need for your own imagination.
Acting is an art form.

Cons of watching movies over reading books

Scenes are often adapted or deleted based on what looks better visually.
Viewers are often left asking questions because scenes from the book not being included.
Characters can often be drastically changed.

Why books are better than movies?

If you’re a book enthusiast looking for arguments for books over movies, these are some of the reasons why books are better than movies.

#1. Books nurture the reader’s imagination

is reading books better than watching movies? A man reading a book

When it comes to reading books, readers have an unparalleled level of control in terms of how they visualize the story. When I first read The Hobbit, I pictured a very different-looking Bilbo Baggins to that seen on screen.

Readers can also move through a story at their own pace and use their imagination to create vivid scenes in their mind’s eye. Sometimes even filling in the blanks where there are questions that need answering.

Not only this, but you also get to experience the book in the way the author intended. When directors make a movie adaptation, they have to decide what scenes are the most action-packed and therefore keep the audience engaged.

This often means that some scenes are cut out from the plot that may seem important to the overall storyline.

The biggest example of this is how characters are described in books. Often characters in books look different in movies.

Frankenstein’s monster comes to mind here. In the book, he is described as:

“He is so gentle, yet so wise; his mind is so cultivated; and when he speaks, although his words are culled with the choicest art, yet they flow with rapidity and unparalleled eloquence.” Frankenstein, Victor Hugo, Letter 4

The monster was intended to be gentle. Frankenstein wanted to create a friend, not the brutish monster that we see in the movies.

#2. Books have more depth than movies

But the biggest argument as to why books might be better than movies is that books often have more depth than films due to the additional time they spend on character development and intricate plot points.

When I talk about depth, I am referring to descriptions. The reader gets more insight into how words are said, how characters look, and how scenes are created.

The small details in a book, such as short scenes or little descriptions, are the parts of a book that help readers ask the right questions, start to piece parts of the story together, and even predict what will happen next.

There are usually some key depth features that are missing in movies.

#3. Movie adaptations miss out on key points

If you think about the number of hours you spend reading a book compared to watching a movie, then you get an idea as to how much is missing.

Films tend to lack some of the detail and nuance found in books due to time constraints. This usually leads to unanswered questions after watching the movie.

One of the biggest examples of this is in Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows.

In the movie, there is a scene in which Harry sees a patronus charm of a doe, which leads him to a pond covered in ice where he discovers the sword of Griffindor beneath the surface.

If you watch the movie without reading the book, this scene would be somewhat confusing.

While we do later learn that Severus Snape’s patronus is a doe, and therefore alludes to him placing the sword for Harry to find, the movie never answers the question: how does Snape find Harry?

We also don’t learn how Snape has the sword in the first instance and why it never fell into the ministry’s hands.

While I absolutely loved the movies, I can honestly say I loved it more because I had read the book prior to watching and was able to fill in the blanks.

My partner has never read the books (yes I know, a book blogger is dating someone who has not read Harry Potter. Dumpable offense? Let me know in the comments) and he was constantly badgering me with questions to which I always responded with “in the book, this happens”

#4. Reading has other benefits

There is more to reading books than just following a story. Reading helps to grow your knowledge, expand your creative horizons, and even helps improve your mood.

According to Healthline , reading books can help strengthen your brain, both cognitively and in terms of your mental health.

So you see, there are many reasons why reading is important , not just for something fun to do!

#5. Books allow the reader to think more deeply

Books often have an underlying theme or moral tone that allows the reader to think deeply about certain topics or situations.

The storylines can help you to empathize with certain characters, and reflect on how situations would be handled in our own world.

In classic literature books such as 1984 , for example, there are a lot of areas in which the reader can think about how political influences shape society, but in the movie, you do get a sense of this but it is less developed than in the book.

Why are movies better than books?

If you’re looking for arguments for movies being better than books, here are some reasons why you may prefer a film vs a book.

#1. Movies help bring hard-to-visualize scenes to life

Movies offer a unique cinematic experience that allows viewers to sit back and enjoy a story without having to actively think about it.

This is great for those who don’t have a vivid imagination or struggle to see a clear picture of what an author is describing in their mind.

Movies provide visuals that can often be breathtakingly beautiful or incredibly intense, sometimes more so than written in a book.

One great example of this is in The Hobbit: Battle of the Five Armies.

In the book, Bilbo is hit on the head and knocked out for the whole battle. Only when he awakes does Gandalf fill him in on what happens, but it’s short and to the point.

When you watch the movie, you see all these incredible stunts and action-packed scenes.

Yes, it does feature some gravity-defying performances from Legolas who does not appear in the books, which is something Peter Jackson decided to add to the storyline to make the Lord of the Rings and The Hobbit franchise more connected.

But in the book, you don’t get any of that.

#2. Acting is an art form

Something that readers may not appreciate about movie adaptations is the acting.

Acting is an art form, and by watching movies, audiences can appreciate acting performances as well as special effects such as CGI or stunts that would be much more difficult to experience in a book.

#3. Movies are quicker than books

Reading often requires more time and effort than watching a movie. Reading a book from start to finish usually takes a few days with breaks in between.

If you do sit down to read from start to finish, you can take several hours to get through the entire story.

One reason why you wouldn’t want to do this is that you will instantly forget what happens or you won’t appreciate the detail enough.

Reading should be savored like a fine wine, allowing you to digest information and ponder on the themes, morals, and messages.

If you don’t have time on your side, then movies are your saving grace.

#4. Social interactions are more relatable in movies

Often times when I am reading the dialogue in a book, I feel it’s too staged, or unnatural.

When dialogue is spoken in a movie, it can feel more authentic, as often actors will improvise the script and make it feel more real.

#5. You can watch a film with friends

While you can always go to a book club to talk about a book you love, this is really an activity that hardcore readers enjoy more.

When you go to the cinema, it becomes a larger social outing that can bring together people with all different hobbies and interests.

Should Books Be Made Into Movies?

So while you can now see there are many pros and cons to books and movies, the question remains; should books be made into movies?

Absolutely.

While we can all agree that there is less detail in a movie than in a book, I personally feel that when a book I love has been made well on the big screen, I love the book more.

The best example of this is Lord of the Rings. It doesn’t matter how many times I watch the movies or read the books, I fall in love with the story and characters all over again.

I also find that when I’m not in the mood to read, watching a movie brings back fond memories of the book and helps me get out of a reading slump and inspired to read again.

And it’s not just me that thinks this. According to a study by SuperSummary , 82% of people agree that movie adaptations bring a book to life.

Books vs Movies: The Verdict

Ultimately, which form is better comes down to personal preference as both offer unique experiences that shouldn’t be compared side by side.

While books allow you to use your imagination to its fullest, movies allow the viewer to follow a story without concentrating.

You get more depth to a plot from a book, but you spend less time watching a movie.

Whichever way you choose, whether it’s curling up with a good book or settling into your couch for some movie night fun, there can be no doubt that both will result in an enjoyable escape from reality.

Like this post? Don’t forget to save it on Pinterest!

About Louisa Smith

Editor/Founder - Epic Book Society

Louisa is the Founder, Editor, and Head Honcho of Epic Book Society. She was born and raised in the United Kingdom and graduated from the University for the Creative Arts with a degree in Journalism. Louisa began her writing career at the age of 7 when her poetry was published in an anthology of poems to celebrate the Queen's Jubilee. Upon graduating university, she spent several years working as a journalist writing about books before transitioning to become a Primary School Teacher. Louisa loves all genres of books, but her favorites are Sci-Fi, Romance, Fantasy, and Young Adult Fiction. Read more Louisa's story here .

Find a blog post

Books vs. movies: the age-old debate.

The Mountain Between Us , It , Murder on the Orient Express , Wonder , My Cousin Rachel . These films released in 2017 have one thing in common, and you may have guessed it already: They were all books that were later adapted into movies.

Similar to its affinity for sequels and remakes , it seems to me like Hollywood is increasingly looking to books for inspiration for the next blockbuster hits. From a business standpoint, it makes total sense because producers can draw on the popularity of a certain book and use that to their advantage when it comes to marketing the film’s release.

As an avid reader, I am always excited at the news that a book is being adapted as a feature film. My mind is occupied by thoughts of who the actors/actresses are going to be (and if I approve), if the film will stay true to the book, and most importantly, if the movie will be just as good as the book. The thought of finally being able to visualize what has only previously been limited to my imagination is always an exciting prospect.

However, I am usually underwhelmed after watching a certain film based on a book, and if you asked me a year ago which one I would prefer: the movie or the book, I would have immediately chosen the book.

Hands down. No doubt. However, within the past year, I have come to appreciate movie adaptations of books more because I have realized that comparing books to their counterpart movies isn’t fair; at the end of the day, the two mediums of storytelling have different advantages and different qualifications for what makes them good. Like Stephen King once said, comparing one to the other is like comparing apples to oranges. They are both great sources of entertainment, but they aren’t comparable. For those still reluctant to accept this theory, I’ll be delving more into this age-old question: “What’s better: books or movies?” I’ll make a case for each argument and let you make the final call.

The popular belief is that books are often a hundred times better than their movie counterparts; if you need any further proof, just take a look at the following Washington Post visual.

Books are great because they allow the reader to be a part of the story; we are the observers that have insight into the character’s thoughts and feelings, and all the nuances that create three-dimensional characters. With books, there’s just more. More detail, more focus on character development, and more depth to the meaning of the artwork. It’s also the more time-consuming form of the two, and after finishing a novel, after a couple of hours of being immersed into a different world and mind space, it seems like you have suddenly been thrust back into reality.

On the other hand, the great thing about movies is their ability to show, and the overall experience of watching one. While reading a book, I often have a movie reel playing in my head. I can map out the setting, I can see the characters’ expressions, and I can empathize with their emotions.

However, watching the same story unfold on the big screen is a different experience. While reading spurs your imagination, a movie helps you visualize all the elements of the books that were previously confined to your imagination. It immerses you into the story in a different way than a book.

For example, instead of reading about the magical world of Harry Potter, while watching the movie, I can actually see what J.K. Rowling means by “He was almost twice as tall as a normal man and at least five times as wide. He looked simply too big to be allowed, and so wild – long tangles of bushy black hair and beard hid most of his face, he had hands the size of dustbin lids and his feet in their leather boots were like baby dolphins.” To put it simply, movies make it easier for us to just lean back and enjoy the show.

An added benefit of movies is the music and visual designs that enhance the experience of watching a film. Imagine, for example, that you are watching an emotional scene. It’s the climax of the story, and in the background plays a gentle orchestra, that eventually swells into a big crescendo as the story reaches its resolution. In that moment, you feel exactly what the characters feel, and your heart races along with the melody of the music. So although (in some cases) the audience might not have a play by play of the characters’ thoughts and emotions, movies have another way of conveying the emotion and tone of a certain scene.

If you feel like further exploring this age-old debate personally, come down to Media Services to check out movies even the worst critic would have to admit are just as good as the books. Don’t know where to start? Try Pride and Prejudice, Psycho, Jaws, The Godfather, etc.

Until next time! RE

Robiati Endashaw is a sophomore studying public policy analysis in KSB with a minor in Economics. In her spare time, she enjoys reading non-fiction and watching crime documentaries.

Oh gee thanks so much . I also feel quite the same way too when it comes to books as in they are so much enjoyable because they allow us as the reader to explore the depths of my imagination and every thing happening Is felt dearly. 😊

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed .

Social media

Instagram for Herman B Wells Library
Facebook for IU Libraries

Additional resources

Featured databases.

Resource available to authorized IU Bloomington users (on or off campus) OneSearch@IU
Resource available to authorized IU Bloomington users (on or off campus) Academic Search (EBSCO)
Resource available to authorized IU Bloomington users (on or off campus) ERIC (EBSCO)
Resource available to authorized IU Bloomington users (on or off campus) Nexis Uni
Resource available without restriction HathiTrust Digital Library
Databases A-Z
Resource available to authorized IU Bloomington users (on or off campus) Google Scholar
Resource available to authorized IU Bloomington users (on or off campus) JSTOR
Resource available to authorized IU Bloomington users (on or off campus) Web of Science
Resource available to authorized IU Bloomington users (on or off campus) Scopus
Resource available to authorized IU Bloomington users (on or off campus) WorldCat

IU Libraries

Diversity Resources
About IU Libraries
Alumni & Friends
Departments & Staff
Jobs & Libraries HR
IU Libraries Blog
Intranet (Staff)
Login (Blogs admin)

Presidential Search
Editor's Pick

Cambridge Residents Slam Council Proposal to Delay Bike Lane Construction

‘Gender-Affirming Slay Fest’: Harvard College QSA Hosts Annual Queer Prom

‘Not Being Nerds’: Harvard Students Dance to Tinashe at Yardfest

Wrongful Death Trial Against CAMHS Employee Over 2015 Student Suicide To Begin Tuesday

Cornel West, Harvard Affiliates Call for University to Divest from ‘Israeli Apartheid’ at Rally

Watching, Not Reading

Movies mean big business. They are popular, far-reaching, and, with any luck, entertaining. The movie industry, though, does far more than entertain us—it plays an active role in shaping our collective consciousness. Of course, this was not always the case; the written word once reigned supreme as the chief means of influencing public opinion. However, motion pictures are increasingly becoming the primary modes of spreading information and educating audiences. This phenomenon, despite the accompanying demise of the supremacy of books, is a tremendous boon: It offers the potential to effectively educate society and add to our shared culture.

Gone are the times when a simple pamphlet like Thomas Paine’s Common Sense could incite a revolution. Hard as it may have tried, Newsweek was never able to achieve the authority that print publications used to command, and has, as a result, become be the latest casualty in the industry. Even online written content, with the possibility of reaching billions of viewers, fails to influence public perception as words once could. The only pamphlets capable of provoking rebellions today are largely restricted to 140 characters in length.

In many respects, movies are usurping written works as the primary means of spreading ideas and educating the public. Films do not merely entertain; they educate. The public, for instance, was first truly exposed to King George VI, the British monarch during World War II who struggled with a stutter for the entirety of his life, not through a history textbook or popular novel, but by the Hollywood hit “The King’s Speech.” I learned more about the six American escapees during the Iranian hostage crisis by watching a two-minute trailer on YouTube for Ben Affleck’s new flick “Argo” than I picked up from years of history classes and their accompanying textbooks. Educating the public is always a benefit to society, regardless of the means by which information was imparted.

The effectiveness and influence of movies may be at least partly due to their inherent nature. As visual, rather than textual, stimulus, they display content much more quickly than can a book. Movies, then, are better vectors to reach and inform a vast audience. Moreover, the concrete images of film are easier to remember long after their display than the imagined ones required for reading. A picture, we are told, is worth 1000 words, and most films play at a rate of at least 24 frames per second. At that speed, Ben Affleck’s “Argo,” running 120 minutes long, is worth well more than 200 King James Bibles.

I do not mean to imply that a movie is qualitatively better than a piece of literature merely on account of its ability to display more content. Rather, this characteristic may explain our tendency to prefer and learn better from films than from books. Watching a motion picture is an inherently more passive experience than reading a book. Yet it imparts content in a much more easily consumable way than a book of commensurate length. Movies are more tangible, visual, and compact than comparable written works, and are therefore easier to remember. To lament the popularity of films relative to books is to simply ignore the potential benefit they offer society.

Critics point out that the potential for misinformation in movies is great: Not all historical films are necessarily accurate. The creative liberties taken are not always as obvious as those involving mutants averting the Cuban missile crisis. Politicized documentaries, such as “2016: Obama’s America” and Michael Moore’s “Fahrenheit 9/11,” are characterized by the unabashed misrepresentation of facts. But history books, too, have never been completely accurate. One elementary school textbook claimed that thousands of black soldiers fought for the Confederacy, a definitively false claim. In fact, enough uncredible history books abound to warrant an entire contest sponsored by the History News Network.

Factual inaccuracies aside, the film industry goes beyond entertaining and even teaching the public; it reshapes the historical narrative in the public consciousness in a way books no longer do. When people think of the RMS Titanic, they remember Leonardo DiCaprio and Kate Winslet fighting for survival in the icy waters of the Atlantic. Similarly, Spielberg’s Lincoln will surely reshape the narrative of Abraham Lincoln’s presidency the way Oliver Stone’s JFK retold Kennedy’s assassination to the American public. These films demonstrate the potential of film to popularize history, educate the public, and reshape our collective culture.

Film is nothing new. Hollywood’s influence on American culture and consciousness is long established. However, the industry is expanding its influence beyond the confines of the United States and reaches a broader, more international audience than ever before . In our era of globalized culture, we may someday see motion pictures eclipse the written word as the primary means of education everywhere. Movie theaters are, in some ways, becoming global classrooms, and movies bestselling books. Some may be upset that films are replacing written works as cultural agents and education tools. But Argo looks pretty darn good.

Jacob R. Drucker ’15, a Crimson editorial writer, lives in Mather House.

Want to keep up with breaking news? Subscribe to our email newsletter.

To Watch or to Read: The Great Debate of Books vs. Movies

The debate between books vs. movies has been raging for decades. Some people prefer the immersive experience of reading a good book, while others enjoy the visual and auditory spectacle of a blockbuster movie. While both mediums have their own unique advantages and disadvantages, there is no denying that they both offer a powerful and engaging way to tell a story.

In this article, we will explore the pros and cons of both books and movies and delve into the reasons why some people prefer one medium over the other. We will also examine the impact that film adaptations have had on the literary world, and how books and movies have influenced and inspired each other over the years.

Through this exploration, we hope to provide a better understanding of the book vs. movie debate and help readers decide which medium they prefer. Whether you’re a die-hard bookworm or a film buff, there’s no denying that both books and movies have a place in our cultural landscape. So sit back, relax, and join us as we explore the great debate of book vs. movie.

Book Vs Movie: Compare And Contrast

Books vs. movies: The age-old debate. Here’s a chart summarizing the key differences between books and movies:

These are just a few of the many differences between books and movies, and there is no right or wrong choice when it comes to deciding which medium you prefer. It ultimately comes down to personal preference and what you enjoy most in a story.

The Advantages of Reading a Book Over Watching a Movie

Books and movies are two very different forms of media. While movies can be visually stunning and entertaining, books offer a deeper, more immersive experience that simply can’t be replicated on the big screen. In this section, we’ll explore some of the key advantages of reading a book over watching a movie and find out the reasons why good books are better than movies.

Reading a book offers a more immersive experience than a movie, as it allows readers to delve deeper into the story and form a stronger connection to the characters. With more extensive descriptions of people, places, and events, readers can visualize the story in their own way and bring their own experiences and perspectives to the reading experience. This personal connection is not possible with a movie, which visualizes the story for the viewer.

Books Vs. Novel - A Reader Enjoying His Favourite Book

Reading also has cognitive benefits, improving memory, focus, and concentration, as readers actively process and make connections between story elements. Additionally, reading expands vocabulary and language skills, exposing readers to a wider range of words and sentence structures.

While movies have their own unique advantages, such as a cinematic experience and visual and auditory stimulation, reading a book offers a deeper, more engaging experience that cannot be matched by any other medium. Overall, the benefits of reading make it an essential and highly rewarding activity.

The Advantages of Watching a Movie Over Reading a Book

While there are numerous advantages to reading a book, there are also many reasons why watching a movie can be a more enjoyable and fulfilling experience. In this section, we’ll explore some of the key advantages of watching a movie over reading a book and find out the reasons why movies are better than books.

Movies have a distinct advantage over books due to their visual medium, which can create stunning visuals, deliver visceral impacts, and transport viewers to different worlds. Movies are also more convenient than books, as they require less time and effort to enjoy. Additionally, movies are accessible to a broader audience, including young children and those with limited literacy skills.

Books Vs. Movie - Enjoying a Movie in a Theater

Finally, movies offer a shared experience that can bond friends and family and create lasting memories. While books offer a deeper, more immersive experience and can improve cognitive functioning and language skills, movies should not be overlooked. Movies are an essential and valuable part of our culture, and their unique advantages should be appreciated.

The Importance of Originality: The Book vs. Movie Debate

The importance of originality is a crucial factor in the debate of book vs. movie. Books and movies require originality to stand out in their respective mediums.

In books, originality is crucial to the success of the story, as readers are looking for something new and fresh. Authors who can deliver original and compelling stories are more likely to attract a loyal following of readers.

On the other hand, movies need to offer something unique and different from what has come before to succeed in a crowded marketplace. Audiences want to be entertained and challenged, to see something they haven’t seen before. The challenge lies in adapting a book for the screen, as movies need to capture the essence of the original story while also offering something new and original to viewers. A successful movie adaptation captures the spirit of the original story while also offering something fresh and unique to the audience.

Overall, originality is crucial for both books and movies to be successful and memorable.

The Impact of Film Adaptations on Book Sales

Film adaptations of books have become common in the entertainment industry, and their impact on book sales is significant. A successful movie adaptation can result in a surge of book sales and increased attention for the author. However, a poorly received adaptation can damage the reputation of the source material and turn potential readers away.

The impact of film adaptations on book sales can also vary depending on the genre of the book , with young adult novels having a particularly strong impact. A successful adaptation can also lead to increased interest in the author and their other works.

Books Versus Movie - Best Selling Harry Potter Book Series

Nonetheless, the relationship between books and movies is complex, and a delicate balance must be struck between staying true to the source material and offering something new and original.

Despite the challenges, it is clear that the relationship between books and movies is important, with each medium having the potential to influence and enhance the other.

Comparing the Popularity of Books and Movies: A Statistical Analysis

This section explores the popularity of books and movies by analyzing sales figures and audience engagement.

According to the Association of American Publishers, book sales in the US reached $25.8 billion in 2020, while global box office revenue for movies was $42.2 billion in 2019. However, these figures are not necessarily indicative of overall popularity, as the success of a book or movie can depend on various factors such as genre and marketing.

In terms of audience engagement, a survey by the Pew Research Center found that 65% of American adults reported reading a book in print or digital format in 2019, while data from the Motion Picture Association shows that the average US moviegoer attended about 5 movies in theaters in 2019 .

Nonetheless, it is important to note that reading books and watching movies are not mutually exclusive activities, and personal preference and taste play a significant role in determining the popularity of these two forms of entertainment.

Ultimately, both books and movies have the potential to provide enjoyable and meaningful experiences for viewers and readers alike.

Why Some Movies Fail to Capture the Essence of the Book

Movie adaptations of books often face challenges in capturing the essence of the original work. The biggest challenge is condensing the story into a shorter running time, which can result in a movie that feels rushed or incomplete, with important plot points or character development left out.

Another challenge is finding the right tone and style, as books can be written in a variety of styles, from lyrical and poetic to straightforward and simple. Filmmakers may make changes to the story or characters that alter the tone or style of the original work, resulting in a movie that feels different from the book. Inner thoughts and emotions, which are extensively described in books, can be difficult to convey visually, leading to clunky or awkward voiceovers or other techniques.

Lastly, some movies fail to capture the essence of the book simply because they are not faithful to the original work, as filmmakers may make changes that are not in line with the author’s vision.

Overall, adapting a book to a movie is a challenging task that requires balancing various elements such as condensing the story, finding the right tone, conveying inner experiences, and staying faithful to the original work. However, when done well, a movie adaptation can provide a fresh perspective on a beloved story and introduce new audiences to the world of the book.

How Movies Can Enhance or Detract from the Reading Experience

Movies can impact the experience of reading books in both positive and negative ways. While a well-made movie adaptation can bring a story to life in a new way and provide new insights into the characters and settings, it can also limit your imagination and leave out important details or changes that affect the overall meaning of the story

A movie adaptation can enhance the reading experience by providing a visual representation of the story and bringing new nuances to the characters and events. On the other hand, movies can detract from the reading experience by limiting the reader’s imagination and leaving out important details or changing aspects of the story that affect its overall meaning. When a movie adaptation leaves out a key subplot or character, the story may feel incomplete, and if it changes the ending of the story, it can alter the entire meaning of the book.

Ultimately, the decision to read a book or watch a movie adaptation is a personal one and depends on the individual’s preferences and the specific book and movie in question.

Does Reading the Book First Ruin the Movie Experience?

The debate over whether reading the book before watching the movie adaptation ruins the movie experience has been ongoing. Some people believe that knowing the story beforehand takes away the suspense and surprises that make movies enjoyable, while others argue that reading the book first enhances the movie experience.

Those against reading the book first argue that it takes away from the suspense and surprise of the movie and leads to constant comparison with the book. However, reading the book first can also provide a deeper understanding of the story and characters, making the story more meaningful and impactful. It can also help fill in gaps that are often left out in the movie adaptation. Movies have to condense the story, leaving out important details or subplots, which can leave viewers feeling confused or unsatisfied.

Ultimately, whether reading the book first ruins the movie experience is a matter of personal preference. It’s up to the individual to decide whether they want to read the book first or wait to see the movie without any prior knowledge of the story.

The Role of Directors and Screenwriters in Adapting Books for Film

Adapting a book into a film is a challenging task that requires a skilled director and screenwriter to bring the story to life on the big screen. They must carefully decide which elements of the book should be included in the movie, considering the pacing, structure, characters, and motivations, to ensure that the movie stays true to the spirit of the book while also being entertaining for moviegoers. Without understanding the psychology of movie watchers, a movie hardly gets success at the box office. The tone and mood of the book must also be captured in the movie adaptation, which can be particularly challenging when adapting books known for their unique style or voice.

Books Vs. Movies - Bilbo Baggins in The Hobbit

Practical constraints of the movie medium must also be considered, such as deciding which scenes and characters can realistically be portrayed on screen and which elements of the story may need to be altered or omitted to fit within the constraints of the movie format.

The success of a movie adaptation depends on the skill and creativity of the director and screenwriter, who must work together to craft a cinematic experience that stays true to the book while also being engaging for moviegoers. When done well, a movie adaptation can bring a beloved book to life in a new and exciting way, creating a powerful and memorable cinematic experience.

The Future of Books and Movies: Will One Outlast the Other?

The future of books and movies is uncertain, and it is difficult to predict which medium will outlast the other.

Books have been around for centuries and provide an immersive experience, allowing readers to engage with the story and characters. They have a wide range of genres and subject matter, making them accessible to a broad audience. On the other hand, movies offer a unique cinematic experience that cannot be replicated by any other medium. They visually immerse viewers in the story and characters and can reach a wider audience through mass distribution in theaters and online streaming platforms.

However, concerns remain about the future of both mediums. The rise of e-books and audiobooks and the decline of traditional print books are concerns for the book industry, while the decline of movie theaters and the rise of streaming services are affecting the movie industry.

Despite these concerns, both books and movies have shown resilience over time. While the formats may change, the desire for stories and entertainment will always be present. It is likely that both mediums will coexist in the future, with each offering its unique benefits to audiences.

The debate between books and movies will continue as both have their unique advantages and disadvantages, and the choice depends on personal preference. While books provide an immersive experience and movies offer a unique cinematic experience, the impact of movie adaptations on book sales and the role of directors and screenwriters in the adaptation process is crucial. Both books and movies have influenced and inspired each other, but some movies fail to capture the essence of the book.

Ultimately, both mediums have a place in our cultural landscape, and it’s important to celebrate and appreciate their unique benefits while enjoying the stories and characters they bring to life.

So, Keep Watching and Be Bookish !

Dennis K. Hawkins is a writer, blogger, book critic and bookish person. He has written several books and regularly write blogs. As a bookish, he reads a lot and regularly share his opinion regarding books. Besides, he has a huge collection of unique accessories related to book. So, he is an expert and also a real user of the book accessories that he chooses to write on.

How To Telepathically Communicate With Someone

How to telepathically communicate with someone amazes many people. A lot of people make fun of telepathy, but it is true. Telepathy frequently happens between close friends. They often sense the other person’s feelings due to their entangled vibrations and cells. People who have been married for many years tend to experience this most frequently….

Can You Hit Dabs off Wax Paper: Important Thing You Need to Know

Dabs are a great way to enjoy your favorite concentrates without having to deal with the hassle of a rig. All you need is a piece of wax paper and a heat source, and you’re good to go! But what if you don’t have a heat source? Still can you hit dabs off wax paper?…

Are Reading Pillows Good for Your Back: Important Benefits of Reading Pillows

Are Reading Pillows Good for Your Back? Well, we all know how important it is to have good posture and take care of our spine. But sometimes, when we’re engrossed in a good book, it’s hard to maintain that perfect posture. That’s where reading pillows come in! Reading pillows are designed to support your back…

How to Wash Reading Pillow: Important Issues You Need to Know!

If you have a reading pillow that you love, you want to keep it clean so that you can enjoy using it for years to come. Here is how to wash reading pillow. The article is a great solution to your all queries regarding how to wash reading pillow. You may notice that all pillows…

Book Page Holder: A Great Tool for Readers

If you’re an avid reader, then you know the great use of book page holder because it reminds you how frustrating it is to lose your place in a book. Whether your bookmark falls out or you just can’t seem to keep your finger on the page, it’s annoying to have to constantly flip back…

Pen Vs Keyboard: Which is Better? Writing By Hand Vs Typing

In today’s fast-paced digital world, the age-old debate of pen vs keyboard, in other words, writing by hand vs typing, continues to captivate the minds of students, professionals, and creatives alike. The rise of technology has made typing the norm, with keyboards replacing pens as the primary tool for jotting down notes, composing essays, and…

Books Versus Movies With English Teachers

Do you prefer books or movies?

Beth Myers: I prefer books because I’m not good at watching movies.

Josh Bault: I prefer books generally because I feel like you get more detail and more of a cohesive look at the characters.

Nathan Hedrick: I think it depends on my focus level at the time. Movies are easier to enjoy than books but, books give me more stimulation.

Julien Gaumer: I enjoy both books and movies. However, if I were to compare both a book and a movie that was created from the book, then I would choose the book every time.

Which one do you think has more detail?

Myers: In a book, you can only imagine what you know, and in a movie, they can bring in things that you might not have thought about. When I read “The Hobbit,” there was no movie at all. It took like 20 years for a movie to come out, and when I watched that movie, what I saw on the screen was not what I imagined in the book. It was awesome, so much better.

Bault : I think books have more detail. You know it’s kinda hard to shove a 700-page book into an hour and a half.

Hedrick: Books have more detail. They have way more methods and ways they can communicate a story through narrating or description, but in movies, most of the detail has to come through dialogue and speech.

Gaumer: It is difficult for Hollywood to condense the details of a book into a short film. I have found a few films I have enjoyed the same as a book if I had read it first. An example is “All the Light You Cannot See.” Netflix released a series that seemed to follow the book very well. It probably is because it was developed into a series instead of just a condensed movie.

Which do you think is more educational?

Myers: I think they are equally educational.

Bault: I think it depends on the movie. If it’s a documentary, it’s probably more educational, and you get a lot of that information over the course of reading a biography. Books are probably more educational depending on what it is.

Hedrick: They are both educational in both ways. It depends on the educational topic. I think books involve more of your brain to understand the story than movies.

Gaumer: When I see a movie that I am interested in watching that was developed from a book I haven’t read yet, then I try to read the book first. For instance, “The Boys in the Boat” came out on Christmas Day, and my family went and watched it the day after Christmas. I read the book beforehand to compare. Although the movie was a great “feel good” movie and inspirational, the book shared so much more detail about the protagonist and all of the members of the boat, which was even more inspiring. It showed people that positive perspectives and the desire to persevere despite circumstances is a choice people can acquire; indeed, it is a choice.

Your donation will support the student journalists of Logansport High School. Your contribution will allow us to purchase equipment and cover our annual website hosting costs.

As you walk down the hall your eyes wonder to look at all of the bright colors that fill the Foreign language hallway. From Piñatas to traditional chinese decorations the hallways is filled with the work of many students.

The Student News Site of Logansport High School

Advertising
Submit a Story Idea
Order a Yearbook

Comments (0)

Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Student LMS
“The Beacon” Student Newspaper
Merchandise

Current Coupon Codes

The Book vs. the Movie: More Than Meets the Eye

Mar 17, 2021

Which is better: Michelangelo’s The Creation of Adam on the Sistine Chapel ceiling or Haydn’s oratorio The Creation ? While you might prefer one over the other, it’s unfair to declare one as “better” because they are completely different art forms.

How many times have you been excited to see a new movie based on a book you love, only to be disappointed that the “movie wasn’t as good as the book”? Maybe the movie left out characters or changed the plot or just didn’t portray the story the way you did in your mind.

Before I began studying adaptation theory, I failed to view film as a literary form in its own right. After learning how screenwriters adapt books for the screen and why directors make certain choices, I have a deeper appreciation for and understanding of this visual medium and the impactful way it tells a story in a single sitting.

Why Novels and Films are So Different

Novels and films both tell stories, and they both teach us about ourselves and the world around us. But they do so in very different ways. Therefore, we should evaluate and appreciate them as artistically different.

Novels rely completely on words for storytelling. As a result, authors can shape their stories by incorporating the thoughts, feelings, and motivations of characters. They can describe scenes and events—even imaginary ones—with vivid detail. Authors are masters at weaving words together to create just the right tone, mood, and impact, but they are still limited to words.

Films must use different techniques to accomplish the same goals—techniques such as lighting, camera angles, music, special effects, and, of course, acting. While film characters do use words, their stories are propelled and developed primarily through other means. You’ve heard that a picture is worth a thousand words. One perfect camera shot with the right lighting, the perfect sound effect, and an intentional gesture or facial expression on the part of an actor can sum up pages of descriptive text.

Authors rely on readers to fill in some of the details of a scene with the help of their own imaginations. Even the most descriptive of authors can’t tell you every single detail about a room, so a set designer (like a reader) has to fill in those gaps. As a result, it took a whole team many days and dollars to create Miss Havisham’s room from Great Expectations . Charles Dickens created the scene with just a few sentences: “I entered, therefore, and found myself in a pretty large room, well lighted with wax candles. No glimpse of daylight was to be seen in it. It was a dressing-room, as I supposed from the furniture. . . . But prominent in it was a draped table with a gilded looking-glass, and that I made out at first sight to be a fine lady’s dressing-table.” Both the textual and the cinematic versions of this scene are worthy of our appreciation.

Why Is Understanding Adaptation Important?

Every year, more and more literature (both classical and popular) is adapted for the screen. Rather than being passive viewers of these films, we should practice actively analyzing and interpreting them just as we do text. We should contemplate how a visual form of symbolism in a film compares to the written form of that symbolism in a novel. We should even consider how text and film can manipulate our emotions differently.

In many classrooms, teachers have used movies merely as rewards for reading books. Now teachers are recognizing film as a different way of viewing text —a way that encourages analytical thinking and helps students better understand the elements of both mediums. It’s no wonder that film adaptation has become a popular high school and college literature course in the past few years.

In Excelsior Classes’ one-semester English course “From Bookshelf to Box Office: Literary Film Adaptation,” high school students will dive into adaptation history, theory, and analysis. They will read literature and study award-winning adaptations that cover a wide variety of genres and time periods. And they will probably eat a little popcorn along the way!

Dickens, C., & Rosenberg, E. (1999). Great expectations: Authoritative text, backgrounds, contexts, criticism . New York: W.W. Norton.

Stam, R. (2000). “Beyond Fidelity: The Dialogics of Adaptation,” in James Naremore, ed., Film Adaptation (New Brunswick: Rutgers, 2000).

Dawn Burnette is truly excited to be part of the Excelsior family as an English teacher! Dawn holds a B.A. in English Education/Journalism from Lenoir-Rhyne University and an M.A. in English Education from Georgia State University. She has also earned National Board Certification and gifted endorsement. While teaching English at a public high school for 15 years, Dawn served as English department chair, coached a nationally ranked dance team, and won a few local, state, and national teaching awards. Dawn loves sharing her passion for reading and writing, and she works tirelessly to help students reach their academic potential and to glorify God in all pursuits. Soli Deo Gloria!

When it was time for their children to start school, Dawn and her husband Rod moved the family from an Atlanta suburb to the North Georgia mountains, acquired way too many animals, and spent the next 12 years homeschooling. Their daughter Ansley graduated from Samford University in 2022 and works at Sight & Sound Theater in Lancaster, Pennsylvania, and their son Beck graduated from and played collegiate golf at Lee University and the University of Georgia and began playing professional golf in 2024.

The thoughts and opinions expressed are those of the author and should not be taken to represent the views of Excelsior Classes, LLC or the consortium of teachers.

Discover Excelsior Classes

The Excelsior Classes Story

How Excelsior Classes Works

View Available Courses

Parents must first create a family membership account in order to purchase classes.

Parents should purchase classes for one student at a time in the shopping cart. This will allow the registrar to appropriately place your students in the correct classes.

See How to Register for more details.

International edition
Australia edition
Europe edition

Are books better than films?

I went to see Percy Jackson and the Sea of Monsters with the Spinebreakers. We all needed to write something on the film and our views on it. I did my research first. I re-read the book, made numerous notes, wrote down everything I wanted to see in the film and brought a notebook into the cinema with me, ready to jot down my thoughts as the film played out before me.

The film was amazing – seriously, it blew me away. It was so, so much better than its prequel, Percy Jackson and the Lightning Thief, and stuck so much closer to the book – something that obviously made me exceptionally happy.

The people who worked on the film... they got a lot of things right. They got the characters, the world, the creatures, the feel all right. They changed the plot, of course, and missed various things out, adding others in their place. But this didn't matter – Percy Jackson and the Sea of Monsters was absolutely stunning.

So why am I so obsessed with the things they changed? Why am I so much more in love with the book than with the film?

The same thing happened with The Hunger Games. They got almost everything exactly right, but it still... it didn't have the same feel to it. The suspense and emotion just didn't project from page to the screen.

Films... they can do a lot of things. They can bring whole worlds to life before our eyes, make characters into living, breathing flesh and blood. They can have us on the edge of our seats as vicious battle scenes are fought right before us, have us sobbing over a death, a heartbreak or smiling with joy. Films can make us see a lot of things – sometimes things that even books cannot do so well. They are a pure escape – there's nothing like sitting in the cinema, devoid of any other distraction, focused completely on the story playing on the screen.

Films are great, but they just don't have the same...inclusion that books have. You're merely an observer: you aren't feeling everything the character feels, aren't reading every single one of their innermost thoughts, all of their doubts and fears and hopes. Films let you observe everything. Books? Books let you feel everything, know everything and LIVE everything. With a book, you can be the hero who kills the demon with one twirl of your blade. You can be the girl who battles cancer, along with all the pain and uncertainty that comes with it. You can be a demigod, you can be an alien, you can be an angel, a god, a villain, a hero. You can be in love, you can hate, you can triumph, you can lose. You can be anything and everything. There are no limits. No restrictions. Nothing is impossible, nothing is out of reach…

And that… that is why books are always better. When you read a book, nothing else exists and you can be a whole other person in this completely new and amazing world. You can live as someone else, free of your own troubles, even if only for two hundred pages.

Books are magic. Which is why I'm telling you all to forget about movie magic and get back to the pure magic that lives upon your bookshelves. Because while the movies are good… the books are ALWAYS better.

Do you think books are better than films? Send us your thoughts - [email protected] - or join the discussion on Facebook

Your responses

ABitCrazy The thing is... most days people prefer to have a day sitting in front of the television watching the latest films and TV shows; some people even just watch TV for the sake of watching TV and they're willing to watch any old junk. And it's more common to find people that prefer to sit in front of the television all day than it is to find someone that wants to sit at home reading all day. I love reading with a passion; I love letting my imagination run wild and imagining what all these characters look like and how they're feeling. Films don't do that for you but books do! Almost all books that become bestsellers get turned into films and sometimes the films really please you and sometimes it can be soul-destroying!

Two of my favourite series of books have both been turned into films - The Hunger Games and Twilight.

And after watching the first Hunger Games it totally ruined the book for me forever. I can't imagine the Hunger Games the way I used to when I re-read the book. The Hunger Games was somewhere to escape to on a good or bad day; it made you forget where you were and start being a different person, even if it only lasted the length of a book. It felt like it was my life and not Katniss's but now that I've seen the film I no longer imagine how the characters looked and reacted to everything. But watching and reading Twilight didn't feel quite like that, because when Twilight first came out in cinemas I was to young to watch it so I wasn't interested in it but as we all know Twilight is now one of the most popular teen books and movies ever! So once I got to the age of wanting to watch and read the books it was too late to think up my own imagination of the book because by then I had seen and read so many things about Twilight I already knew most of what happened. So films in some ways ruin books for children. And if the Hunger Games turns out like Twilight - all the people that are too young to watch it now but might when they are older will have already seen all the trailers and read all the articles in magazines - the experience of reading the book will be totally ruined for them.

And then you have people that just skip the book and go straight to the film. I understand that some people actually don't like reading so they probably won't read the book but they might watch the film, but to just skip the book completely because they're desperate to watch the film is disappointing. I like to read the books first to know where it all started and why they decided to make a film out of it. I didn't read all of The Host (Stephenie Meyer's other novel) before I saw the film but I did read some of it and it was a great book from what I read but also a great film. And of course sometimes films seem to be the same idea as the book had but are not actually based on the book. So it's a bit like Twilight for instance; Twilight's inspiration came mainly from the American TV show Buffy The Vampire Slayer but had its own little twist. And that's a bit like what films do to books. They make it seem like they've taken the idea from the book but switched it up so it's not actually anything to do with the book.

And for this reason that's why I prefer books to films. Films destroy really amazing books! And TV has changed books. Maybe some people only read books because they're the reason that the films exist and I think that reading a book because of TV and films is a bad way to read; I think people should read a book because they actually want to read the book and every book should be a new story. And of course there are films not related to books at all and books that films aren't based on, and sometimes that is exactly how it should be: sometimes it's best if the two things aren't connected.

Children's books discussions
Children and teenagers
Children's books: 8-12 years
children's user reviews

Books vs. Movies- Which is better in terms of education and entertainment?

My friend and I are in a debate Proposition: The general public should recognize that books have a greater educational and entertainment value than movies.

Terms: Entertainment: The act of diverting, amusing Educational: To develop the mind

We are the Con side, thus saying that Movies have a greater eductional and entertainment value.

I would like your guys’ opinion, which do you consider better and why? Please try to include both factors, education and entertainment. Clips would also be appriciated ^_^

Thanks

I find books much more educational and rewarding. There are many reasons for this:

-Books occupy you for a far longer period of time, while a movie only lasts for 2 hours or so. Books can last days, or weeks. -They improve your vocabulary and writing -You can carry a book around with you and read it anytime, while you can’t just sit down anywhere and start watching a movie (excluding ipods or stuff like that)

I love movies but I always found books to be most rewarding.

Hmm. Well I don’t agree 100% but…

If you’re watching a movie that has harder vocab (LoTR even), you can see the way the actor delivers the word, plus you’ll actually here the word. So you may stand a better chance of inferring and then retaining the meaning and the word. Movies may only last 2 hours but they can provoke discussions without being labelled “dorky”. I know at my school if we talked like “OMG! I just read the coolest book…” we’d get some strange looks, but if I was “OMG…Did you guys go see the new … movie? It was so good. I couldn’t believe it was really about…” And so you could get into a discussion that makes you think.

Also if you’re watching a movie, it doesn’t last as long. So if it’s finals week you can sit down and chill, watch a movie… Then go back to studying. Where if you get into a good story you might get wrapped up in it and forget about studying. Plus if I read a book when I was studying, I’d completely lose the text book stuff I just read, whereas a movie, I could easily separate the two.

depends on what movies and books and personal taste.

obviously, reading gossip girl won’t be as good as Vanity Fair. On the other hand, watching Die Hard won’t be as educational as a historical drama.

True, it definitely depends on what type of books and movies you watch. While I love books, I am and have always been a huge movie buff. When my workload isn’t too high, I watch a movie almost every night. Some really can make for some interesting moral, and philosophical debate. Personally, I love a movie that intellectual individuals can debate. I was talking more about educational value. Sure, you hear words used in movies but you can’t see the sentence. That is like being told verbally how to do a math problem. Something about seeing it written out helps make it alot more clear. But I find my sentence structure, vocabulary, and organization much better ever since I started reading on a regular basis. Movies are great, but there is no substitute for a good, old fashioned book

I believe that movies and books belong to two separate categories and that we can not and had better not compare the two. There are things that one can achieve only by reading books and there are pleasures that only come from watching movies. Books used to be used for entertainment, and they still are, but the modern technology and the present movie culture certainly altered, if not complemented, the way we entertain ourselves.

To use a hackneyed analogy: you can not compare an apple with a car. No matter how substitutable each of them seems with each other, there are values carefully and rightfully assigned to them.

Of course one might criticize current movie industries for taking away those who would otherwise find pleasure in reading. I’m in this too, as I’m a voracious reader myself and a self-proclaimed critic of post-modernism. However, reading for pleasure and reading for comprehension are two distinct things, and it would be still absurd to say that just because I watch the movie Twilight when I could be reading Harry Potter, I should stop watching movies.

No. If you are either a serious English student or a voracious reader, you will find pleasures in books(definitely) and in movies(maybe). Detaching yourself from the popular culture means isolation which, while I have a knack for it too, can be costly. Engaging, once in a while, in watching new movies won’t likely affect you and your desire to read, that is, as long as you consider yourself a reader.

Personally, being a movie fan and an avid reader, my penchant for both activities has so far generated complementary benefits and intellectual amalgamation, not hindrance of engaging in either one. I want to talk more about cultural benefits of watching movies, but I certainly don’t think watching movies can replace reading, and vice versa.

In terms of education and entertainment, each have their own values. In the modern world, one would not be deemed “educated” without ever watching any movie which essentially is a new type of “culture” that we as moderns are very, very privileged to enjoy.

Also, considering ubiquity of reading and its long-lasting history, I doubt that no matter how advanced we might become, we will keep reading. The accumulation of knowledge and literary works that have been amassed thus far in either printed or digital form in the last thousands of years are far superior than the superficial, entertainment-focused movies that have been produced in perhaps less than a hundred years.

By “movie” I’m assuming you mean something like a documentary rather than, say, a Khan Academy video.

In favor of books:

You can set your own speed for reading them. The only way to do that with movies is constantly pause, rewind, etc. and that gets annoying.
There’s something about the act of reading itself that makes the information sink in better. It’s a lot easier to zone out watching a movie. Reading is a more “active” process than passively watching a movie.
More convenient to carry around.
There is far more material available in book form than there is in movie form.
Not every idea can be easily translated into an image or sound.
Movies are often more sensationalized than books, so as to appeal to the “unwashed masses” who don’t read much.
Movies are often more expensive than books. It costs money to check them out at a lot of libraries.
It’s easier to find exactly what you want in a reference book (movies aren’t indexed, and generally aren’t long enough to be).
Some topics are too obscure/advanced to justify the costs of making a movie.

In favor of movies:

Not everyone can read well, and some people just don’t enjoy reading no matter what they do. These things should be remedied as best as possible, obviously, but in the meantime people can learn from movies.
Some people aren’t great at visualizing things and would get more out of a movie image than a description in a book.
Movies make it easier to convey emotion/connotation/context.
It’s very hard to learn foreign language pronunciations from a book.
Books have had thousands of years to develop, and they’ve probably gotten as good as they’re ever going to get. Movies haven’t been around long at all, so they’re still developing and improving.

Solid 6 year bump.

POPULAR STATES

Search sat scores, search act scores, search gpa’s, subscribe to our newsletter.

Stay informed with the latest from the CC community, delivered to you, for free.

CONNECT WITH US

Books or movies: which is better?

By Timothy Durkin

Books and movies are very different forms of entertainment, yet the two are compared often. Books require the reader to imagine the world and characters for themselves, while movies want the viewer to focus more on the visuals. However, for the sake of argument, it can be fun to debate which medium is better. Here I will be explaining why books are much more enjoyable, but movies can be good as well.

I think it is important to get my inherent bias for books out of the way first. I have been an avid reader since my earliest years in grade school, and while I have slowed down since then, I still consider myself a fan of literature. I also consider myself somewhat of an amateur collector, but I will not lie and say that I have multiple full bookshelves worth of books. That being said, I do think there are some aspects of books that are objectively good, regardless of bias.

I believe the strongest aspect of a book is how it makes the reader think. When watching a movie, it can sometimes be easy to let your brain go into autopilot. For books, reading without thinking is nearly impossible because you are actively engaging with the text the entire time. If you are not reading and therefore engaging, you cannot be progressing in the book. Books are also able to get the reader to imagine marvelous worlds and scenes, especially in genres like fantasy and fiction. In film, you do not have to imagine the world because it is right in front of you.

Books are also more rewarding to experience and finish. With movies, you typically sit down and finish the film in one sittings. Books are a completely different story.

Books are also more rewarding to experience and finish. With movies, you typically sit down and finish the film in one sitting. Books are a completely different story. Depending on the piece, it could take multiple days or even weeks to finish one. Finishing a huge 900 page book like “The Goldfinch” by Donna Tartt is one of the most satisfying feelings in my opinion.

This next aspect is backed up by nothing but my own personal experience, but I feel it important to note anyway. I find myself having more fruitful discussions about books than I do movies. For example, when I read “Slaughterhouse-Five” by Kurt Vonnegut, my friends and I discussed it for well over two hours afterwards. In comparison, when we watched the 1972 film adaptation, we discussed it for maybe 10 minutes. One could argue that the movie just was not very good, and while I would agree, I do think it is a common trait that most movies share. “To Kill a Mockingbird” by Harper Lee, legitimately one of the best books that can be read, is a favorite of mine. I watched the highly regarded 1962 film adaptation, and I had hardly anything to say beyond praise for the acting. To me, there is something special missing from most movies.

Now, while I think that books are better than movies, that is not to say that movies are always worse in every aspect. For instance, some genres work much better as visual stories than written ones. The horror film genre completely outclasses the book genre purely because things are scarier to see than read. Movies can also be beautiful in their own way. Appropriate music choices, interesting shot composition and casting choices are all missing in books, and they can make or break some films. 2022’s “The Batman” took all these strengths and used them to create a movie that was just as good as any book, but in a completely different way.

Speaking of differences between books and movies, I think it is time to address a big topic of debate: movie adaptations of books. While I could spend an entire op-ed on this alone, I will try to keep it brief here because it depends on the director’s vision. J. K. Rowling’s “Harry Potter” series worked better in film because all of the wacky spells that the wizarding world used looked better when they were actually seen. Rick Riordian’s “Percy Jackson” series failed in the film industry because the film was radically different from what the fans expected. Stephen King’s “The Shining” was a 1980 film directed by Stanley Kubrick, but the two are so disconnected from one another that they may as well be different stories with the same characters. There are a lot more examples that I could pull from, but I think that I made my point. There are just too many variables to really determine if the books are always better than their film counterparts.

While I ultimately prefer books over movies, I do think that there is an argument to be made for the opposite opinion. Books and movies are both great forms of entertainment in their own special and unique ways. Even though I am more inclined towards books, I still watch movies somewhat consistently. Both are valid ways to spend your time, and as long as you think that your time is being spent well, that is all that matters.

Higher Education News , Tips for Online Students

14 Educational Movies No Student Should Miss!

Updated: December 7, 2023

Published: January 23, 2017

14 Educational Movies that Can Change the World

Educational movies aren’t limited to non-fiction films, narrated in monotone and projected onto a whiteboard in darkened classrooms that you’ve sat through at some point in your academic careers.

Good educational films are also movies you’ve seen in theaters. Like good teachers, they have challenged, inspired, scared, angered, and moved you. Here are 14 of the best movies for students that are fun to watch but also have some important messages.

Educational Movies for Students

1. good will hunting .

Actors: Matt Damon, Robin Williams, Ben Affleck, Minnie Driver, Stellan Skarsgard

Genre: Drama

A janitor at M.I.T. is discovered to be a mathematical genius after solving a graduate-level equation nobody else has been able to. His brilliant mind comes with a troubled personality and he’s unwillingly paired with a therapist as part of a probation agreement after getting arrested. While the math professor who wrangled the probation agreement only sees him as a project, the therapist sees the whole person and pushes him to have the courage to create his own path.

This heartwarming movie delivers important messages about being true to yourself, the importance of solid friendships, and using your gifts even in the face of fear and self-doubt. This remains among the best films for students!

2. Freedom Wr iters

Rated: PG-13

Actors: Hilary Swank, Scott Glen, Imelda Staunton, Patrick Dempsey, Mario

A young English teacher takes a job teaching at-risk students at a high school where racial tensions run high and gangs are ever-present. Her world is much different than theirs and she struggles to make connections. Her dogged devotion to her students slowly breaks down barriers and using her own money she buys composition books in which they can write about their lives – abuse, violence, neglect, hope, and dreams.

More than one tear will be shed while watching this movie that shouts that our humanness ties us together and that perseverance in following your dreams despite overwhelming odds is a battle worth fighting.

3. Race to Nowhere

Directors: Vicki Abeles, Jessica Congdon

Genre: Documentary

The idea for this powerful documentary came about after Vicki Abeles’ middle-school daughter became physically ill from the pressure to succeed. Race to Nowhere takes a critical look at the systemic problem of pushing kids to the brink in the American education system. Burdened students, burned-out teachers, and worried parents tell their stories.

This is one of those educational movies that will have you thinking about your own priorities and whether you’re taking on too much. If you’re an education major, this is a must-see in the category of films for students!

4. Lean on Me

Actors: Morgan Freeman, Beverly Todd, Robert Guillaume

Genre: Drama/Action

New Jersey’s Eastside High School is a derelict war zone with rampant violence, drugs, gangs, and a student body that isn’t learning. The school is set to be turned over to State administration unless 75% of the students can pass the minimum skills tests. The new principal, known as “Crazy Joe” is hired right away and shakes things up in a big way. Do his students succeed? You’ll have to watch it!

Lean on Me is clear about its messages that life often involves some very hard choices, fierce dedication has the power to change lives, and that students in lower socio-economic areas are too often cast away.

5. Theory of Ev erything

Actors: Eddie Redmayne, Felicity Jones

Genre: Romance/Drama

Astrophysics student Stephen Hawking trying to determine a thesis topic. After a lecture on black holes, he surmises that these holes may have been a part of creation and decides to write about them. He’s diagnosed with motor neuron disease and is told what that means. His love, Jane, is determined to stay with him but after several years of trying to raise children, care for Stephen, and manage writing her own thesis, it’s apparent that the marriage is no longer realistic. But the divorce isn’t the end of the story.

The themes in this fascinating film include endurance, perseverance in the face of hardships, and selfless love. The theory of everything needs to be on the list of best movies for the classroom!

6. The So cial Network

Actors: Jessie Eisenberg, Andrew Garfield

Genre: Drama/History

This is one of those educational movies that anyone who uses the social media platform Facebook should watch! It traces the journey of jilted boyfriend Mark Zuckerberg as he creates a platform called Facemash which allows others to rate girls on their attractiveness. Zuckerberg is found out and given academic probation but invited to help run a social network for Harvard students developed by three others. Zuckerberg then approaches an investor about his idea for Facebook and conflict is born. The twins are incensed and as Facebook becomes wildly popular a trail of lawsuits begins to follow Zuckerberg.

This movie should be listed among the ideal educational films for older students. It will challenge your ethics, make you question why and how you use social media, and create discussions around privacy and internet safety.

7. Life of Pi

Actors: Saraj Sharma, Irrfan Khan, Rafe Spall

Genre: Adventure/Drama

A great story about a man named Pi whose family owns a zoo. His father decides they will move to Canada and will sell the animals there. A terrible storm sinks the ship and Pi finds himself in a lifeboat with a zebra, an orangutan, a hyena, and a tiger. Eventually, it’s just Pi and the tiger after the hyena kills the zebra, and the orangutan and the tiger kill the hyena. When he is rescued he tells this story but nobody believes him. And then, a twist.

On the surface, this seems to be one of those fantastical movies for the classroom that students will enjoy. But there’s much more to it and will raise questions about survival, truth in storytelling, and faith.

8. The B lind Side

Actors: Sandra Bullock

Genre: Sports/Drama

Based on a true story of a teen who has bounced around foster care due to a drug-addicted mother. He gets a break when a friend’s father asks the football coach of a Christian school to help enroll him. He makes the team but struggles with places to live and when the mom of a teammate finds out he’s sleeping outside, she invites him home. Slowly he becomes part of this family despite the many challenges and bumps along the way.

The Blind Side is a heartwarming tale about looking beyond outward appearances, trust, loyalty, the power of athletics, and that family isn’t always blood.

9. Girls Ri sing

Producers: Kaycee Freed, Tom Yellin, Holly Gordon

Girl Rising is a global movement for education that was born from this film that features the stories of nine girls from different locations around the world. They share their struggles to overcome the cultural and social barriers that females in their countries face daily.

This film will teach you about the struggles that females face in other countries because of social and cultural barriers and how they fight for an education.

10. The Great Debaters

Actors: Denzel Washington, Forest Whitaker

Genre: Drama/Romance

A debate coach at a historically black college strives to see his team considered equal with white teams during the racist era of Jim Crow, lynching, and beatings. Black people were not allowed to be full members of the debate society and any win against a white team was not recognized – even a championship.

This is one of the more powerful films for students as we grapple with our history and our future. Topics include racism, Jim Crow, perseverance against all odds, and being a champion at heart.

11. A Plasti c Ocean

Rated: Not rated

Producer: Craig Leeson

What began as a search for the elusive blue whale ended in the discovery of plastic trash in what should have been a pristine ocean. Journalist, free diver, scientists, and researchers document their travels to 20 locations around the world to discover just how much plastic waste has fouled our oceans and how that’s impacted those creatures who live in its waters.

This film will likely leave you stunned as you begin to understand the scope of how humans are destroying the planet. It will inspire you to take the small steps that can make a difference.

12. Int o the Wild

Actors: Emile Hirsch, Marsha Gay Harden, William Hurt

Genre: Biographical/Drama

A young man, disenchanted with modern society, treks, completely unprepared, into the Alaskan wilderness. In his backpack are a few camping supplies, meager clothes, and a bag of rice. He intends to live off the land but he discovers Alaska exacts a heavy price from the foolish.

Into the Wild touches on several themes including humankind’s longing for simpler times, living life connected to the Earth, mental health, the cost of being unprepared for challenges, and the sheer strength of the human spirit.

13. T he Pursui t of Happyness

Actors: Will Smith, Jaden Smith, Thandiwe Newton

A hardworking but down-on-his-luck salesman has a chance encounter with a partner of an investment firm. This gives him the opportunity to become one of 20 unpaid temporary interns competing for one permanent job at the company. But the financial tension dissolves his marriage and soon he’s on the streets with his young son in tow. Despite the trials and tribulations, he sets his sights on beating out all the other interns for that full-time position.

This moving feature film teaches the audience that nothing is impossible, that sometimes hard work does indeed pay off, and that there is still compassion in this world.

14. A B eautiful Mind

Actors: Russell Crowe, Jennifer Connelly, Ron Howard

An Ivy League student, with a brilliant mathematical mind, attracts the attention of the Pentagon and is invited to help decipher encrypted enemy communications. Things go south when he begins to struggle with schizophrenia which manifests itself in an imaginary world of spies and intrigue.

A Beautiful Mind tackles the often misunderstood world of mental health in general, and schizophrenia in particular. Viewers will understand how important a good support system and medical care are and the film helps to destigmatize mental illness.

Final Thoughts

Educational movies are a key component of learning and the majority of films aren’t written just to entertain. There are messages of hope, endurance in the face of seemingly insurmountable obstacles, and the power of the human spirit.

Movies can challenge you to be and do better and to take the first steps to make the world a much better place. Take every opportunity to enjoy a great movie and some popcorn and consider the message the writers and actors are trying to convey!

Substitute Teacher

Is there anything more exciting than the squeaky wheels of the TV cart coming down the hall?

With all the after-school screen time children are consuming along with their snacks, parents might not exactly be psyched to learn that their kid is spending their 5th period watching movies, too. But before you call the principal’s office or start composing a highly combustible Twitter rant, remember that many students are visual learners and teachers’ go-to movies actually accompany their classroom lessons, rather than replace them.

Many English teachers especially are big fans of screening Shakespeare films along with assigned readings (remember, the swoony romance of Romeo & Juliet is actually meant to be experienced as a drama between actors, not necessarily read on the page). And movies can make dusty texts feel fresh and new. Ethan Hawke’s Hamlet , for example, retains the Bard’s Elizabethan English, but upgrades the action to a modern setting (the famous “To be, or not to be” soliloquy is delivered while a beanie-clad Hawke is roaming a now-defunct Blockbuster store).

We talked to teachers from coast to coast, who work in grade schools and high schools, to see what educational and entertaining movies light up their classrooms. From courtroom dramas to animated rainforests, musicals to time travel, there’s a movie on this list for every kid to learn from and later recap to the rest of the family at the dinner table. While desks are clearly not as comfortable as theater seats, and there probably won’t be any candy either (a win for parents!), at least students won’t be overcharged for greasy popcorn.

And don’t worry, there won’t be a test at the end!

Watch 'Just Mercy' starring Michael B. Jordan & Jamie Foxx and streaming on Amazon Prime.

Staci Lamb , a 9th grade teacher at Elkton High School is not just an award-winning educator, she boasts an impressive Instagram community with over 60,000 followers. When it comes to movies to show in the classroom, Lamb is a big fan of Just Mercy , starring Michael B. Jordan and Jamie Foxx. The powerful true story about inequality and injustice follows Bryan Stevenson, a Harvard grad, attorney, and social justice activist who defends people that are wrongly convicted, and went on to found the Equal Justice Initiative .

The movie centers around one of his first clients, Walter McMillian, a man sentenced to die for the murder of an 18-year-old girl, despite evidence of his innocence. “Just Mercy captures Bryan Stevenson’s work so beautifully and invites students to analyze and reflect on Stevenson’s claims,” says Lamb, who is the 2018 CCPS Teacher of the Year in Maryland and best-selling author of Keeping the Wonder . “ It’s a powerful adaptation of an incredible true story that captivates students.”

Watch Just Mercy , rated PG-13, on Amazon Prime.

Watch 'Inside Out' streaming on Disney+.

Inside Out is an animated movie that takes you inside the mind of an 11-year-old girl named Riley as she faces a big life change: a move from Minnesota to San Francisco for her dad’s new job. This clever, high-concept film creates characters out of the emotions Joy, Sadness, Fear, Disgust, and Anger.

Darin Nakakihara , a teacher in Southern California who spent most of his career teaching 4th grade, appreciates how Inside Out honors kids’ inner lives, which can often be overlooked in a school setting. “Growing up can be tricky. I love how the story is built around things that the kids are dealing with during our time together and beyond — dealing with emotions,” says Nakakihara, who connects the way characters handle different feelings with his students’ experiences throughout the year. “None of this is in our curriculum, but it's something they all must learn how to navigate if they want to grow into productive members of our society.”

Watch Inside Out , rated G, on Disney+ .

Bill & Ted’s Excellent Adventure

A movie about two spacey teens who can’t stop saying “party on, dudes!” might not seem like the most academic film to screen in class, but it turns out this 1980s classic is chock-full of mini history lessons, as well as memorable quotes (as when Ted waxes philosophical to Socrates: “All we are is dust in the wind, dude.”).

Andrew Christopher, who teaches 10th grade Global Studies in Roosevelt Island in NYC, screens this Keanu Reeves classic at the end of the year because it’s a movie that highlights world history and — let’s face it — is boatloads of fun. “Bill and Ted travel back in time to learn about history and pass their global history final exam. In doing so, the characters collect important historic figures from the past, including Abraham Lincoln, Genghis Kong, and Napoleon Bonaparte, to participate in a final presentation that brings the historic periods from which they came to life in front of the class.” And hey, even if the history lessons weren’t in the movie, there’s a case to be made for students learning that Reeves is the perfect specimen of humanity , even before his Matrix days.

Watch Bill & Ted’s Excellent Adventure , rated PG, on Amazon Prime .

Ferngully: The Last Rainforest

FernGully is an animated fantasy movie that takes place in the Australian rainforest. When a fairy named Crysta discovers a human lumberjack named Zak, she shrinks him down to her miniature size and invites him into her world of wonder and beauty. Starring the late and great comedian Robin Williams as a manic bat, FernGully has a strong environmental message that really resonates with educators.

Todd Nesloney , who has taught elementary school and was the principal of a PreK-5th grade campus, is a fan of the film that catalyzes conversation and takes on logging and pollution. “ FernGully shows how we all play a part in what happens to others,” says the author, speaker, and director of Texas Elementary Principals & Supervisors Association (TESPA). With a soundtrack by Elton John, Raffi, and “Wild Thing” rapper Tone Loc, this magical ecological movie that teaches kids to protect the rainforest will have you spellbound.

Watch FernGully: The Last Rainforest , rated G, on Apple TV .

Dear Evan Hansen

Once one of the hottest tickets on Broadway, this musical’s film adaptation will pierce the tender heart of anyone who has ever felt isolated in high school (in other words, everyone). Ben Platt delivers a powerhouse performance as Evan Hansen, an outcast aching to belong in the social media age, who becomes entangled with a family grieving a son who died by suicide.

Lisa Septimus , a veteran teacher and director of student life at North Shore Hebrew Academy, gives an A+ to a movie that breaks the silence surrounding mental health challenges. “One theme of the show is showing how common it is to struggle with mental health and how often people feel alone and suffer because of it,” says Septimus. “Being able to be honest about difficult feelings makes them suddenly more manageable. That’s what Evan finally learns to do at the end.” While Septimus concedes that musicals in movie form can sometimes be corny, she gives a big thumbs-up to the plot changes the filmmakers made, including when the protagonist “embraces his authentic self including flaws and fears.”

Watch Dear Evan Hansen , rated PG-13, on HBO Max .

This movie is such a ginormous hit with kids, it probably doesn’t need any introduction. But in case you’ve been living under a Bruno-free rock, Encanto is the enchanting story of a girl named Mirabel Madrigal, who is the only member of her family without magical powers. Not even celeb kids can resist belting out the music from this Disney blockbuster (“We Don’t Talk About Bruno” actually hit No. 1 on the Billboard Hot 100 chart !). If North West and Gene Schumer can’t stop singing these bops, your little ones probably haven’t stopped either.

Special education teacher Andrew Militscher, who works with 4th and 5th grade students at Andrus Orchard School, can speak to his own students’ obsessions with these catchy, cinematic tunes. Militscher says that Encanto is his movie of choice for a very simple but compelling reason: “The kids love to sing ‘We Don’t Talk About Bruno!’” And while the lyricism of Lin-Manuel Miranda is a masterclass unto itself, Encanto’s message that representation matters is even more compelling than its music.

Watch Encanto , rated PG, on Disney+ .

Twelve Angry Men

A gripping story of bias and judicial injustice that is still as relevant today as it was in the 1950s, Twelve Angry Men is a courtroom drama that takes place over one tense afternoon, when jurors decide the fate of a teenager who is alleged to have murdered his father.

Leora Klein, founder of Uncommon Advantage and a learning specialist at Abraham Joshua Heschel High School in Manhattan who also teaches English language and literature, is quite fond of the classic film. According to Klein, “English teachers always tell their students show don’t tell. This film shows (rather than tells) the power of the individual to stand up, speak up, and affect change.” Klein is also a co-founder of 3GNY and director of WE Educate (WEDU) , an educational non-profit that empowers the grandchildren of Holocaust survivors to bring the accounts of survivors into the classroom, so this educator walks the walks when it comes to teaching kids to avoid being bystanders and face bigotry head-on.

Watch Twelve Angry Men , unrated, on Apple TV.

The Great Debaters

In a time when so much student conversation takes place on screens or with abbreviated or grossly misspelled texts, it’s great for young people to discover the lost art of elocution and get reacquainted with the power of the spoken word. The Great Debaters is based on a true story that follows the incredible journey of a debate team at a historically Black college during the 1930s. Denzel Washington plays charismatic debate coach Melvin B. Tolson, who leads his students to incredible heights in a time when lynchings and Jim Crow laws were still common. Jurnee Smollett plays one of the only female debaters on the team and delivers a stirring rebuttal that will rouse any crowd.

As a teacher of both public speaking and rhetoric, Adam Bowman champions a movie that demonstrates his syllabus in action, sparks vital dialogue, and is a great example of Black Excellence. “The historical context and issues about race the film presents also engender the type of classroom discussion our students — and our country — needs,” says Bowman.

Watch The Great Debaters , rated PG-13, on Amazon Prime .

Coco is a delightful family movie that tells the story of one 12-year-old boy named Miguel and his larger-than-life adventure to the “Land of the Dead” to discover his ancestry. The computer-animated film follows a young boy’s dream of becoming a musician and ultimately overturning his family’s ban on music. Inspired by the Mexican holiday Day of the Dead ( Día de Muertos), which celebrates family members who have passed, the movie has garnered heaps of praise for celebrating Mexican folklore and culture with a Latino cast.

Imani Hamami, a lead teacher at Manhattan Children’s Center , a school known for its world-class treatment of autism and related disabilities, appreciates the positive impact Coco ’s songs have on her students’ spirits and how they provide a vehicle for teaching Mexican culture. Her students “love to sing along and pretend they are playing the guitar,” she says. Coco is a sing-a-long that inspires students to follow their dreams, especially when it takes them to unexpected places.

Watch Coco , rated PG, on Disney+ .

The Graduate

OK, so maybe the image of a young Dustin Hoffman glimpsed from between the legs of the older woman trying to seduce him might not be the first thing you think of when it comes to educational movies, but The Graduate is one of America’s most critically acclaimed films.

Veteran teacher and administrator Alice Bowman, who is the current middle school principal in Plainview-Old Bethpage, definitely agrees. Bowman is a big proponent of this ‘60s movie about adulting as a recent college grad (with a bonus playbook for breaking up a wedding). “When I taught Mass Media to seniors in English, my favorite movie to show was definitely The Graduate . I loved it because it had so much to offer the kids in terms of cinematography. It is such a classic, has a killer soundtrack, and speaks to the coming of age that they’re all experiencing.” Compared to things that that “kids these days” are consuming (ahem: the ultra-scandalous Euphoria ), The Graduate is squeaky clean by comparison and is actually rated PG. But if you’re not sold on the academic value of dissecting themes of alienation, counterculture, and female sexuality , at least your kids will come away with a necessary lesson on Paul Simon’s discography.

Watch The Graduate , rated PG, on Amazon Prime .

Teachers are some pretty smart people ( they’re heroes , really). So kids are in good hands when they watch ones of these gold-star movies picked by someone who knows a thing or two about how to grow a big brain.

This article was originally published on Aug. 10, 2022

Exhibitions
Photo/Video

The Magic Of Fantasy Books

How to use online digital platforms to stream and monetize music, new york’s first permanent immersive art center to open this summer, oscar nominees 2022 where art plays a role, 6 advantages of using movies for educational purposes.

Most people only view films as entertainment, but this should not be the case since movies play a significant role in the education system. Unfortunately, many parents who have school-going kids believe that movies are addictive and disruptive in their children’s academic lives. However, teachers use popular educative films because they believe they will improve students’ education and bolster their understanding of a particular subject.

Besides boosting students’ academic abilities, movies also play a significant role in improving teachers’ training skills and their way of handling different situations since most educational films feature common challenges that are faced in schools, such as:

Rebellious youths
Underprivileged kids
Kids struggling with substance addictions
Kids suffering from terminal illnesses or certain disorders

Unfortunately, using traditional learning methods alone might fail to motivate most children. However, most kids love to be entertained, and it might be hard to think of a better way of including entertainment in education than through inspirational movies and plays. Let’s have a look at some of the incredible benefits of incorporating films in education.

Boosting Memory

The best and most effective method of enhancing memory is repetition. It involves going through a particular subject more than once, which might be a boring task. Fortunately, when topics are put in films, students can go through them many times without getting bored. This is mainly not the case when it comes to reading a book several times.

Moreover, moving pictures are easier to remember; hence, during exams, scholars will vividly recall the answers to questions asked in the educational films, which can help them score better in their papers.

Movie Education Improves Understanding

In this era, teachers and parents have realized that using one teaching method can fail to boost understanding of a particular lesson. Therefore, they blend movies with other techniques to create diverse teaching methods. Watching a film on a certain topic makes it easy to understand, as all senses are engaged during this time.

However, students might lack time to watch a movie, research repeatedly, write, complete, and hand in their assignments on time. In such a situation, employing an essay writing service might help manage your time and submit your paper on time.

Dual-Coding

This means combining the verbal and visual presentation of information to help students acquire new concepts on a particular topic. It regularly happens when they read or learn certain subjects in the classroom and then watch a subject-related film. This allows scholars to process knowledge in different ways hence boosting their learning abilities and retaining any new information for a long time. Dual coding is one of the best methods for enhancing academic performance.

Movies Education Is Inspiring

Without inspiration, there would be no motivation in life. When people feel inspired, they struggle to better their lives and get the required energy to fight and overcome a tough situation. Most movies inspire people to reach particular levels in their lives. When students watch these movies, they see how people change and become heroes/heroines in different life scenarios.

Scholars can also learn the various these heroes and heroines did to get there. They learn that an ordinary person can achieve something great and be recognized globally. It helps them see life from a different point of view and hope that they, too, can achieve anything, even what might seem impossible to accomplish.

Raising Awareness

Some films are specifically made to create awareness on matters affecting society. They address issues such as:

Social beliefs
Cultural values
Economic issues

Movies help people know and appreciate the stated issues. Therefore, students can see the significance of these values and learn to appreciate the different lifestyles people live and whatever they went through to get to where they are now.

Enjoyable Learning

Students need to find a subject enjoyable to perform well in it. Therefore, using movies in the classroom is entertaining, especially given its ability to welcome change. This, in turn, is a great way of ensuring students remain motivated and interested in a particular topic. Teachers and parents who use films for tutoring purposes also find it enjoyable and interesting.

Final Thoughts

In conclusion, parents and teachers should exercise caution when using film education since some movies may not offer the desired educational advantage to children. Besides, parents should monitor whatever their children are watching by first reviewing it. This will always allow them to control what students watch to ensure they only watch educational films. In conclusion, it’s worth noting that studies reveal that entertainment can motivate students to enjoy and remain in school to complete their studies. Fortunately, movies play a significant role in offering the desired entertainment when learning.

Style Hunter

The rubells show off their shiny new prodigy, downs & ross’s director steps back, and more juicy art world gossip, studio visit: video: a studio visit with pat steir as she prepares for the hirshhorn, yuga labs is inviting owners of cryptopunks to purchase physical versions of their nfts at a 48-hour print party, masterworks from the diamonstein-spielvogel collection to be offered at sotheby’s new york, dutchman on trial for robbing a collection of roman coins in germany from the rhineland state museum, art industry news: a school board erupted after parents alleged ‘anti-christian messages’ were hidden in a student’s mural + other stories, miami developer craig robins’s beachfront mansion—complete with a zaha hadid-designed bathroom—has hit the market for $45 million, a revelatory karl lagerfeld exhibition at the met is a testament to the designer’s vision and range, celebrate earth day with 13 nature-inspired works from the artnet gallery network, after attempts to save it, the studio of kurt schwitters—who escaped nazi germany to become one of england’s great absurdists—is to be sold, most commented, original oil paintings by leigh j. mccloskey, amok island paints modern minimalist murals of native flora and fauna, world-famous artist-illustrator inge löök will give you a mood for the whole day, paper artworks by pippa dyrlaga, self-portrait of suffering: life and paintings of artist frida kahlo, natural sculptures by andy goldsworthy, radiant identities: photographs by jock sturges, a man discovered an architectural treasure of the xiv century in his house, 10 most famous paintings by norman rockwell, the symbols hidden on the frescos of the sistine chapel are deciphered, editor picks, exhibited for the first time in the u.s. – new sculptures..., popular posts, a man discovered an architectural treasure of the xiv century in..., popular category.

Fine art 392
Photo/Video 381
Art market 379
Exhibitions 330
Auctions 211
Website promotion Elit-Web

National Geographic Education Blog

Bring the spirit of exploration to your classroom.

Men Prefer Movies to Books

Men prefer to watch film adaptations of books rather than read the original, according to a new study. Researchers found the opposite is true for women. (BBC)

Luckily, Nat Geo has great recommendations for both movies and books .

These boys in Chennai, India, seem to prefer their media on a screen, not a page. A new study of 2,000 British men found that 75% preferred a movie version of a story. Photograph by Mariajoseph Johnbasco, National Geographic Your Shot

Discussion Ideas

Usually clocking in at about two hours, movies are a faster way to follow a story.
Movies are often easier to follow, with streamlined plots, action, and character interactions.
Books are usually more accessible and affordable than movies. You can check out a book from the library pretty soon after it’s published, for free.
Books usually provide more backdrop and plot than movies.
Books are often much more imaginative than movies—it doesn’t cost as much to imagine and describe a foreign world as it does to render it onscreen.
Characters: Are the characters in the movie similar to the ones in the book? Are there characters that are in the book that aren’t in the movie? Do you think that character changes influence the tone, meaning, or quality of the film? (Many Lord of the Rings fans, for instance, were disappointed at the absence of the character of Tom Bombadil in the movies.)
Setting: Was the geography of the movie as you imagined it from the book? Did the filmmakers change the setting? (When Alfred Hitchcock made a movie version of Daphne du Maurier’s story The Birds , for instance, he changed the setting from Cornwall, England, to Bodega Bay, California.)
Plot: Did the filmmakers retain the basic conflict and story of the book? (Stephen King’s The Shining , for instance, has a lot more genuinely supernatural and ghostly elements than the Stanley Kubrick film .)
Resolution: Does the film end the same way as the book? Is the conflict resolved? (The 1995 adaptation of Nathaniel Hawthorne’s The Scarlet Letter , for instance, famously changed the entire conclusion of the book.)
Right now, I’m reading The Book of Legendary Lands by Umberto Eco, my favorite author. It’s all about imagined landscapes, from 221B Baker Street to the 100 Acre Wood. Unfortunately, I can’t imagine there being a movie made about such a scholarly analysis.
As for movies, you cannot, cannot, get a better lesson in geography than The Warriors . It’s based on a book , as well as an awesome story from ancient Greece .

2 thoughts on “ Men Prefer Movies to Books ”

the reason behind this is perhaps men’s heavy dependence on visual stimuli . it is plain evolutionary thing.

Yes absolutely right..!!! Because men are not waiting so much time in reading books and all. But men are preferred movies than books. Lol i also the same. thanks for sharing the article.

Why Generation Z Learners Prefer YouTube Lessons Over Printed Books

Fifteen-year-old Jaimie Moreano is on YouTube all the time.

She can learn how to do anything she wants using the video-sharing platform. She uses it to watch hair and makeup tutorials and get-ready-with-me videos to see what’s cool to wear.

But makeup tutorials aren’t the only videos she watches on the popular video platform.

“When I’m doing my homework, I’ll look up how to solve a problem on YouTube,” said Moreano, a sophomore at Locust Valley High School outside New York City. “I like it because it’s really easy to follow. I can pause it, or I can rewind it if I have a question.”

She’s part of a majority of Generation Z kids who have a higher preference for learning from YouTube and videos, compared with printed books. That shifting preference is driving curricula and technological changes in some school districts, but also raising questions and concerns about the downsides of relying too much on video.

In a survey released last month of people ages 14 to 23—the so-called Generation Z group— YouTube ranked the highest as a preferred learning tool . Fifty-nine percent picked YouTube as a learning preference, 57 percent chose in-person group activities, 47 percent picked learning apps or games, and 47 percent chose printed books. The study—conducted by a global market research firm, The Harris Poll, on behalf of education company Pearson—examines the differences between Generation Z and Millennials—defined as ages 24-40—when it comes to their outlooks, values, and experiences in education and the use of technology.

The Generation Z age group has a “specific brand relationship” with YouTube, said Peter Broad, the director of global research and insights for the education company. “When younger learners are looking for answers, they’re going to the most straightforward, familiar force, and for them that’s YouTube.”

The Google-owned platform is “full of explainers and tutorials” and content that is “short and easily digestible,” he added.

‘Grasp the Concept’

Those Generation Z preferences are driving significant changes in some school districts.

In the Mineola school district outside New York City, Superintendent Michael Nagler has been encouraging teachers to use more video in the classroom. The district has a YouTube channel for educators and students , with videos covering topics from growth mindset to science and math lessons. Videos complement the regular curricula and give students real-life connections about why they’re learning something, Nagler said.

“If all the facts and figures are available on the internet, then students don’t need to sit and listen to you,” Nagler said. “But what’s the bigger connection? Videos can give them that bigger connection, engaging them in the content and lesson itself.”

Despite his enthusiasm for the power of video learning, Nagler emphasizes that teachers still need to be the ones guiding students through the content.

The members of Generation Z seem to agree. According to the Pearson study, 78 percent of respondents said that teachers are “very important to learning and development.”

For younger learners who have grown up with technology, it’s all about efficiency and using any resource they can get their hands on easily, Broad said.

“They want to learn as quickly as possible,” he said. “Their assumption is that [the answers they need] will be available to them.”

YouTube is a good source when Moreano has a test coming up, she said. She just types “crash course” on whatever subject the test is on and she’ll find YouTube videos of “people simplifying everything,” helping her to really “grasp the concept.”

Privacy and Content Concerns

Educators and researchers alike agree that young people’s tendency to gravitate toward YouTube has to do with the fact that they’ve grown up with this technology and expect it to always be available to them. The website launched in 2005, around the same time the Generation Z age group was growing up.

Andrew Biggs, a social studies teacher at New Technology High School in Napa, Calif., said that students like YouTube because “it’s on-demand content.”

For students, the strength of video is that you can play and pause it “as many times as you want, without having to feel like you’re inconveniencing someone,” Biggs said. It also makes sense to use it for learning because “a lot of students already use YouTube recreationally.”

The video-sharing website is widely popular among kids and young adults.

A recent Pew Research Center survey found that 85 percent of U.S. teenagers use YouTube , and 32 percent say they use the video-sharing platform more often than other social media platforms. Forty-seven percent spend three or more hours a day on YouTube, according to the Pearson study.

YouTube, however, has recently been accused of targeting children with advertisements and violating the Children’s Online Privacy Protection Act , Education Week reported in April. More than 20 consumer advocacy groups filed a complaint with the Federal Trade Commission , alleging that YouTube has been gathering data of children to target advertisements.

It has also been criticized for recommending inappropriate content to children, said Josh Golin, executive director of Campaign for a Commercial-Free Childhood, one of the advocacy groups that filed a complaint with the FTC. YouTube recommends videos that contain “extremist viewpoints, conspiracy theories, violent and adult content,” he said.

The platform is also “designed to keep you watching one video after another, exposing kids to risks,” Golin said. It’s something educators should think about before sending students to YouTube for educational purposes, he added.

Students also have concerns.

Eva Clark-Dupuy, a junior at New Technology High School, said she uses YouTube as a learning tool because it’s more accessible to her.

“It’s a free app,” she said. “It’s easy to look at. You get millions of results when you search something.”

But the downside of YouTube being a “free-for-all space,” she said, is that anyone can upload a low-quality or misleading video, and the videos could contain inappropriate content.

Other students are concerned that the video-sharing platform is becoming more commercialized.

“Even the YouTubers themselves are advertising products, and you don’t know whether to believe them or if they’re just getting paid to say that,” said Ben Danialian, a senior at Mineola High.

The Role of Visual Learning

The preference for YouTube and videos signals a shift in learning styles, Pearson’s director of global research and insights said. The role of video and visual learning is “essential in rising learners and the generation to come,” Broad said. Pearson has also found that there is growing interest in other video-based learning platforms like Khan Academy.

Some teens are turning to YouTube because they find that it’s easier to understand something when they watch someone explain it visually. It also helps that they can pause and rewind a video if they don’t understand it right away.

Watching a video can be more helpful than having someone lecture at her, Clark-Dupuy said.

“Sometimes learning from a textbook doesn’t help me,” she said. “Sometimes it’s much easier to watch a video on a topic. If I have a visual, it’s easier to grasp.”

The visual aspect of videos isn’t the only reason younger learners are turning to YouTube. They also find the videos more relatable than books.

Moreano said that YouTube is “almost more personal than reading a book, because you see them and what they’re actually doing, and not just what they’re writing.”

She also gets to follow people her age, which makes the video-sharing platform better than a book, she said, because “books feel old to me.”

A version of this article appeared in the September 12, 2018 edition of Education Week as Why ‘Generation Z’ Learners Prefer YouTube Lessons

Sign Up for EdWeek Update

Edweek top school jobs.

Students listen to a lesson on Black fraternities and sororities during Ahenewa El-Amin’s AP African American Studies class at Henry Clay High School in Lexington, Ky., on March 19, 2024.

Sign Up & Sign In

To revisit this article, visit My Profile, then View saved stories .

Backchannel
Newsletters
WIRED Insider
WIRED Consulting

Rebecca Angel

Movies That Are Better Than the Book

I lived a lonely geeky existence once upon a time. When I heard Lord of the Rings was coming to the theaters, I wanted to go, but had no one to go with. A friend of my sister-in-law said he would go with me, but ONLY if I read all three Lord of the Rings books ahead of time. I love fantasy books. I had been meaning to read them anyway. I enjoyed The Hobbit as a kid, even did a report on it in high school. I was looking forward to it. No problem.

Ugh. It took me an entire summer, and half a dozen books as "breaks" to get through the trilogy. Tolkien's epic prose was foreign to my modern fantasy reader's ears. How long before I realized Sauramon and Sauron were different characters? (That explained a lot...) And speaking of names, holy crap! So many look almost exactly alike. Where was the storyteller's voice from The Hobbit? I felt like I was slogging through a textbook of mythology.

I did get through it; the final book grabbed my attention as characters and plot points came together. Seeing the movie, fresh from the books made me have quite a number of opinions. But the biggest one was this: THANK YOU PETER JACKSON! I was so much more entertained watching the movies than reading the books. And stories are foremost about entertainment.

Whoa, there! Back up a minute before you pounce on me. Before anyone says anything about stories being about learning and transmitting cultural ideas, think back on most of your classroom experience. If the teacher didn't entertain you in some way, you didn't learn anything. All storytellers, no matter what the form, MUST entertain or every bit of learning is for naught. As a storyteller myself I am desperate to share the worlds in my head, but if I can't entertain while I'm doing it, no one will listen. Tolkien failed as an entertainer for me , regardless of the fact that his world and characters were so rich. Jackson had me enthralled, my imagination sparked after the house lights came on, and I even obsessed about the character of Frodo (or maybe it was just Elijah Wood...)

The key there is what format engaged me . Fairy tales, books and comics have all been redone as movies over the years with varying success for different people. Here are two more movies that I found better than the book:

Reading The Count of Monte-Cristo by Alexandre Dumas is like going on a date with a brilliant, charming, handsome man who keeps slapping you in the face. The Count of Monte-Cristo is the ultimate revenge tale, and done very, very well. There is a reason it is a classic. However, when it comes to women, Dumas is a jerk. The only good women are ones that behave like dogs: loyal (even if your master is dead), obedient (never ask questions!) and at best, stay in your room pining for when he’ll visit again with no other social contact. Jay Wolpert wrote the screenplay for the 2002 adaptation. He kept the heart of the revenge tale, while narrowing it down to fit into a movie time frame. And he re-wrote the ending in a HUGE way, especially how it reflects on the main female character. Yay!

Jason Parham

The Biggest Deepfake Porn Website Is Now Blocked in the UK

Matt Burgess

What Is 5G Home Internet? Here’s Everything You Need to Know

Nena Farrell

Twilight by Stephenie Meyer was a badly written book. I mean, the English was poor (and I've read plenty of YA novels that are written beautifully.) I like vampires, I like romance, but I was frustrated by the heroine, and not interested in the main guy at all (boooringly perfect.) My full opinion on it can be read here (along with a song). But the movie was fun! I went by myself on the spur of the moment because I was curious. I liked the cast, and it didn't pretend to be anything more than a teen romance story. Completely entertained for two hours. Catherine Hardwicke directed it. Much better than the book.

I asked the GeekMom community for their own opinions on movies that were better than the book. Lots of discussion and debates on a variety of books and movies ensued – including a big one about True Blood versus the Sookie Stackhouse novels, but since TV series are a different venue, I decided not to include it. There was also some chat on liking books and movies equally. Here are the ones mentioned where the movies were liked better, and why. I think the "why" tells more about the person being entertained than the storyteller. I included the producer, director, or screenplay writer when mentioning the movie. There is so much collaboration in making a movie it is hard to point at once person (like a book's author).

Curious George: In the television show on PBS and in both movies (2006, 2009), directed by Matthew O'Callaghan, George is inquisitive and curiosity is portrayed in a positive light. In fact, I've written about Curious George before and how we love it for using curiosity as an introduction to the scientific method. Whereas in the original books (published in 1940-1960), George's curiosity always got him into serious trouble. I bought a couple of the original books digitally but only read them to my daughter once. I felt they were sending the wrong message. The original books portray curiosity with a negative connotation, enforcing the "curiosity killed the cat" mentality. ~Ariane

The 39 Steps (1935) by John Buchan: Hitchcock's film is clearer and more suspenseful, and we attach to the main characters. Buchan doesn't have women. Or hugely dramatic theater scenes. ~KayM

Princess Bride by William Goldman: Lots of people love the novel, but my love is for the movie (screenplay by William Goldman, directed by Rob Reiner). I just could never engage with the novel but I am not sure that amounts to "better/worse." Toss it up for discussion. ~KayM

Princess Diaries Series by Meg Cabot. The changes in the movie, The Princess Diaries, produced by Whitney Houston, made the story flow better and you felt more for the characters situation. Mia was obviously going through more with her dad being gone and her grandmother's attitude was significantly better. In the books, both the dad and the grandmother irritated me. In the movies, I fell in love with them both. ~Dakster

A Beautiful Mind, screenplay by Akiva Goldsman, because Sylvia Nassar's book went flying over my head. And my husband's (someone who reads Richard Feynman for fun). The movie simplified the math and science dialogue considerably. ~Patricia

Red directed by Robert Schwentke: The movie is incredibly well-cast and charming! Helen Mirrin is awesome and there are a couple of moments that made me go "Daw...." :) The comic mini-series by writer Warren Ellis and artist Cully Hamner, is much darker and intense. I like the movie better. ~Corrina

The Bridges of Madison County, the movie produced by Clint Eastwood, was better. Captured the longing of a housewife not certain she had made the right choice all those years ago. Of course, it had the advantage of Meryl Streep, which the book, by Robert James Waller, did not. ~Corrina

I have to add Fight Club directed by David Fincher. You know how a book will fill in the details left out by the movie? Reading Fight Club by Chuck Palahniuk, I felt like the movie filled in the details left out by the book. That was a thin book made into an awesome movie. ~Amy

I like the Diary of a Wimpy Kid movies directed by Thor Freudenthal better than I like the books written by Jeff Kinney. There, I said it. The movies are more enjoyable as a parent, especially because the actors are all so marvelous, but I believe my daughter likes the books more. ~Amy

Stardust: Saw the movie by Matthew Vaughn and Jane Goldman first, and found the book by Neil Gaiman extremely dull in comparison. ~Mandy

The Devil Wears Prada by Lauren Weisberger was almost unreadable. The movie had wonderful characters played by Meryl Streep, and especially Stanley Tucci. ~Kathy

Here's one, the novelization of the second X-Files book, it WAS the worst thing I'd ever read, until I started 50 Shades of Grey! Seriously I took pictures of some of the pages to remind myself how not to write a book. It's a shame as I love many of the X-Files books and this one included details the film by Chris Carter didn't have time to include, but the writing was atrocious. ~Sophie

Now to come full circle with my story of books versus movies for Lord of the Rings, I love the books now. Maybe not as much as the movies, but pretty darn close. What changed? Reading them out loud with my kids. My good friend Amy is a huge fan of the books and offered to read them aloud to all our children. It has been three years and we're in the second half of Return of the King. What a difference! Reading out loud with a group slows things down, discussion happens, jokes come up, passages are reread. We have been on this epic journey with the characters and each other for so long now, I'm dreading the ending, even though we're all cheering everyone on.

I still believe some stories make better movies than books, but if a movie is really good, it's worth it to give the original book a second chance. What about you? Do you agree or disagree with our opinions on the books mentioned here? Other movies that you found better than the books?

Brenda Stolyar

A Wave of AI Tools Is Set to Transform Work Meetings

Steven Levy

10 Reasons Why Are Books Better Than Movies

There’s no doubt that movies are a dominant form of entertainment these days. They seem to be constantly evolving and getting more and more complex, with higher production values and bigger budgets. However, there’s one problem with movies: they’re not books. Books have been around for centuries, and they show no signs of going away. In fact, books are better than movies in many ways.

Table of Contents

Are movies better than books?

There are a lot of people who would say that movies are better than books. After all, movies provide an experience that is more immediate and visceral than reading a book. They can be more exciting, and they can take you to worlds that you could never visit in real life.

However, there are also a lot of people who would say that books are better than movies. Books can provide a more in-depth and nuanced experience than movies can, and they can often be more emotionally powerful. They can also be more intellectually stimulating, teaching you things that you could never learn from a movie.

Ultimately, it’s up to each individual to decide which is better: books or movies. However, it’s hard to deny that both have their own unique benefits and drawbacks.

In this post, we will talk about why books are better than movies but before that, let’s not forget about the good things movies offer and why movies are better than books(in some aspects).

Why Movies Are Better Than Books?

There are a few reasons why movies are better than books.

First, movies are visual. You can see the characters and the setting, and it’s all in one place. With a book, you have to imagine everything yourself.

Second, movies are more exciting. They have music and sound effects, and they move quickly.

Third, movies are more social. You can watch them with other people and talk about them.

Fourth, movies are easier to understand. You don’t have to read the book to know what’s going on.

These are the reasons stand out for movies over books.

Why Are Books Better Than Movies?

Now let’s move into the benefits of reading books over movies. Here are a few reasons why books are better than movies.

Books provide a more in-depth and well-rounded experience than movies

Books allow readers to use their imaginations and create their own images instead of being restricted to what is shown on the screen. This also means that books can be interpreted in different ways, depending on the reader’s perspective, while movies are generally more one-dimensional.

Books also allow for a greater level of detail than movies. For example, a book can describe a character’s appearance in great detail, while a movie would only be able to show a snapshot of that character. Books can also explore complex topics and ideas that movies cannot handle.

Books can be paused, reread, and analyzed more thoroughly than movies

One of the biggest advantages that books have over movies is that they can be paused. This may not seem like a big deal, but it actually allows for a lot more analysis and reflection. For example, when watching a movie, if something confusing or surprising happens, you only have a few seconds to try and figure out what’s going on before it moves on(In case you are watching a movie in a theater). With a book, you can take your time to digest what’s happening and think about how it fits into the rest of the story.

Additionally, books tend to be more analytical than movies. This is because books are often slower-paced and allow for more description. Movies, on the other hand, are more action-packed and rely more on visuals. As a result, books often provide a more in-depth look at characters and plotlines than movies do.

Books Allow for Imagination

Movies are a visual medium. They show you what the director wants you to see. They are limited by what is possible on screen. With books, your imagination is engaged. You can see anything in your head that you want to. This leads to a more personal experience with the story. As a result, readers can create their own images in their minds based on the author’s description.

Books can be more detailed

Books are more detailed than movies. This means that readers can get a better understanding of the story and all of its intricacies. In movies, it’s often difficult to fit in all of the necessary details, which can leave viewers feeling confused.

There are a lot of movie adaptations of books where you will feel like the movie isn’t much detailed compared to the books you read.

Books have pages after pages to explore a topic, while movies are limited by the runtime. This means that readers can learn more about the story and the characters. In addition, books allow for more complex storylines and character development, which isn’t always possible in a movie.

Books can be interpreted differently

Every person who reads a book will interpret it differently. This is due to the number of different perspectives that books offer. With movies, it’s often more difficult to create a variety of interpretations due to the visual nature of the storytelling. This means that people may not have as much of an opportunity to connect with a movie on a personal level.

Books can stay with you for a long time

Movies come and go. You might see a movie once and never think about it again. But a book can stay with you for a long time. You can keep rereading it, thinking about it, and getting something new out of it every time.

So, books can stay with you for a long time. Most of the time, when you watch a movie you might forget about it within a few days. But a good book will stick with you for weeks, months, or even years.

Stories can be ruined by bad acting

One of the biggest problems with movies is that they can be ruined by bad acting. Actors can completely change the feel of a story through their poor performances.

This is not a problem with books, as the reader can always imagine the characters in their own way.

Books improve your vocabulary

Books can improve your vocabulary. Sure, you can learn new words from movies too, but there’s something about reading that makes them stick in your mind better. A lot of time, books will use words that you wouldn’t hear in everyday conversation. This is a great way to improve your vocabulary and learn new words!

Movies focus more on being commercial and compromise on quality

Books are more likely to be focused on telling a good story and providing exciting and valuable content rather than trying to make a quick buck. This is because books don’t rely on box office sales in order to make money – they can be sold at any time to any customer. Therefore, the focus can be on the story and the content rather than on trying to make the movie as flashy and commercial as possible. This often means that movies are more likely to compromise on quality in order to cram in more commercial elements.

For example, a movie might have a shorter running time in order to fit in more advertisements, or it might use well-known actors who might not be the best choice for the role. In contrast, a book is unlikely to have these same commercial pressures, so it can take time to develop the characters and the story. This often leads to a more satisfying experience for the reader.

Movies have limited storytelling time

Movies have a limited storytelling time. It’s not possible to put all the details of the book in a two hours movie. Hence, movies can miss out a lot of good parts because of it’s limited time.

On the other hand, books do not have any limited time to read. It depends on the reader how fast they can read.

A book can be picked up and put down, again and again, allowing the reader to take their time in consuming the story. Books allow for the imagination to run wild, picturing the characters and scenes in any way possible. This is not to say that movies are not powerful, but books allow for a more personal connection with the story.

Other reasons:

Books are more likely to lead to discussions than movies.

One of the great things about books is that they can lead to discussions. When you’re watching a movie, it’s a passive experience — you watch, and then you move on. But with a book, there are different interpretations, and people can have different reactions. This can lead to some really interesting conversations.

Books can provide new insights with each reading

Whereas movies are typically watched just once, books can be read multiple times and provide new insights with each reading. This is due to the level of detail that books can provide as well as their ability to allow readers to interpret the text in their own way.

In contrast, movies are limited by what can be shown on screen and cannot provide the same level of detail as a book. As a result, movies may not always provide an accurate portrayal of the story that is being told.

Conclusion:

Though movies can be great, they often cannot compare to the experience of reading a book. Books allow for more immersion in the story and can provide a richer experience because readers can visualize what is happening in their minds.

Additionally, books tend to have better storylines and characters than movies do. For these reasons, I believe that books are better than movies. Have you ever read a book that was better than a movie? Let me know in the comments.

25,000+ students realised their study abroad dream with us. Take the first step today

Meet top uk universities from the comfort of your home, here’s your new year gift, one app for all your, study abroad needs, start your journey, track your progress, grow with the community and so much more.

Verification Code

An OTP has been sent to your registered mobile no. Please verify

Thanks for your comment !

Our team will review it before it's shown to our readers.

Speech Writing /

Speech on Why Books are Better Than Movies?

Updated on
Dec 22, 2023

Speech on Why Books are Better Than Movies

What would be your choice – Detailed information, character development, intricate plots, or just some animation on screen? Arguments for and against the idea that books are better than movies depend on the individual.

Johannes Gutenberg, a German Goldsmith, invented the printing press in 1436, which paved the way for publishing books. Today, more than 100 million books exist in multiple fields. Books are often considered our best friend because of the knowledge they offer us. In recent years, there has been a debate on ‘Whether are books better than movies, what can we learn from books which movies lack, etc.’ Today, we will provide you with a speech on why books are better than their movies.

10 Lines on Books Are Better Than Movies

Here are 10 lines on why books are better than movies. Feel free to use them in your school topics.

Books offer an extensive exploration of characters, providing in-depth insights into their thoughts, feelings, and backgrounds.
Reading books allows us to personalize and imagine experiences.
Reading books helps us to visualize scenes and characters according to our interpretations and preferences.
The literary format allows authors to delve into intricate details, nuanced emotions, and complex plots that may be challenging to convey in a condensed movie format.
Books empower us to use our creativity, filling in gaps and envisioning the story in our minds, fostering a deeper connection to the narrative.
Books offer a more leisurely and comprehensive exploration of the story, subplots, and character arcs.
Internal dialogues and character introspection are more effectively conveyed in books.
Books provide a richer understanding of the character’s motivations and growth throughout the narrative.
The reader has the flexibility to pause, reflect, and return to any part of the story,
Books foster a more immersive and contemplative reading experience.

Books are better than movies because you design the set the way you want it to look pic.twitter.com/pImXogDi0i — MobiQuotes (@mobiquotes) December 20, 2023

2-Minute Speech on Books Are Better Than Movies

‘Good morning my classmates and teacher. Today, I would like to express my speech on why books are better than movies. From our imagination to language skills, books offer a more comprehensive understanding of the subject. Books provide us with detailed information, character development, and complicated plots.’

‘Reading the written words allows us a deep exploration of the character’s thoughts, emotions, and motivation that is more challenging to convey through a movie. We can visualize the character through our imaginations. Books can delve into the internal thoughts and monologues of characters, providing insights into their minds.’

‘The visualization power offered by books does not judge characters based on their looks, something which movies do. In a movie, only a selected character can play a role, but in books, no such thing exists.’

‘As readers, we can control the pace at which we want to consume a story. we can linger over a beautifully written passage, reread sections for better understanding, or skip ahead if we are eager to know what happens next. Movies, on the other hand, have a fixed pace set by the director and editors.’

‘Movies have time constraints because of which certain elements of a story are omitted or skipped. Reading books requires active mental participation, as we need to interpret the text, imagine the scenes, and connect the dots.’

‘Books can offer multiple perspectives, internal dialogues, and diverse narrative styles that may not be as easily conveyed in a visual medium.

‘Books possess a transformative power, which moves lack. This power goes beyond time and technology, through which we can embark on our personal growth, self-discovery and exploration.’

‘Whether we are reading academic or non-academic books, it’s always a great experience to understand it from our perspective. Whether books are better than movies depends on individual preferences, and both mediums have their strengths and unique ways of storytelling.

Thank you.’

Ans: Books offer in-depth details about the characters, their personalities, thoughts, emotions, and background. Almost every movie has time constraints, where we are required to finish it in the given time frame. On the other hand, books offer us the flexibility to read anything and anywhere. To watch movies, we need proper resources like a TV, laptop or cell phone with an internet connection. Books are easy to carry and don’t need any resources.

Ans: Books keep our minds active and engaged, and offer is diverse range of words and expressions which enhance our vocabulary. Reading books reduces stress levels, improves focus and concentration, enhances imagination and creativity, etc.

Ans: Books provide us with detailed information, character development, and complicated plots. Reading the written words allows us a deep exploration of the character’s thoughts, emotions, and motivation which is more challenging to convey through a movie. We can visualize the character through our imaginations. Books can delve into the internal thoughts and monologues of characters, providing insights into their minds.

For more information on such interesting speech topics for your school, visit our speech writing page and follow Leverage Edu .

Shiva Tyagi

With an experience of over a year, I've developed a passion for writing blogs on wide range of topics. I am mostly inspired from topics related to social and environmental fields, where you come up with a positive outcome.

Connect With Us

25,000+ students realised their study abroad dream with us. Take the first step today.

Resend OTP in

Need help with?

Study abroad.

UK, Canada, US & More

IELTS, GRE, GMAT & More

Scholarship, Loans & Forex

Country Preference

New Zealand

Which English test are you planning to take?

Which academic test are you planning to take.

Not Sure yet

When are you planning to take the exam?

Already booked my exam slot

Within 2 Months

Want to learn about the test

Which Degree do you wish to pursue?

When do you want to start studying abroad.

January 2024

September 2024

What is your budget to study abroad?

How would you describe this article ?

Please rate this article

We would like to hear more.

Have something on your mind?

Make your study abroad dream a reality in January 2022 with

India's Biggest Virtual University Fair

Essex Direct Admission Day

Why attend .

Don't Miss Out

IMAGES

5 Times The Movies Were Better Than The Books
How Books Are Better Than Movies Infographics by thomasrichard
Top 8 Educational Movies To Inspire Your Child
Top 17 Best Educational Movies For Kids In 2023
Is the Book Better Than the Movie?
[Education] 5 movies that are incredibly educational for students

VIDEO

How Arnold Schwarzenegger impacted the film industry
More than Books "KCPL Circulation Services"
5 educational movies a kids should watch
How superhero movies have become the new type of action film
Top Ten Reasons Why Books Are Better Than Movies
10 Famous Educational Movies

COMMENTS

Book vs. Movie: A Survey Settles the Debate Over Which Is Better
Nearly 32% said that the movie was too different than the book, 13.4% of people said the film lacked key details, and a little more than 10% of those surveyed didn't like the approximate two-hour movie time limit. Although respondents were divided on whether they prefer reading vs. watching, they were more aligned with the most-watched adaptation.
Books Vs Movies: Which Is Better? The Debate Settled!
Acting is an art form, and by watching movies, audiences can appreciate acting performances as well as special effects such as CGI or stunts that would be much more difficult to experience in a book. #3. Movies are quicker than books. Reading often requires more time and effort than watching a movie.
Books vs. Movies: The Age-Old Debate
Books are great because they allow the reader to be a part of the story; we are the observers that have insight into the character's thoughts and feelings, and all the nuances that create three-dimensional characters. With books, there's just more. More detail, more focus on character development, and more depth to the meaning of the artwork.
Watching, Not Reading
Watching, Not Reading. By Jacob R. Drucker. November 9, 2012. Movies mean big business. They are popular, far-reaching, and, with any luck, entertaining. The movie industry, though, does far more ...
The Powerful Impact of Movies on Education: How Films Can Enhance
By using movies in the classroom, teachers can create a more interactive and dynamic learning experience. Moreover, movies can be a great way to break up the monotony of lectures and textbooks and keep students engaged and interested in the material. Conclusion. In conclusion, movies can play a powerful role in education.
To Watch or to Read: The Great Debate of Books vs. Movies
Movies are also more convenient than books, as they require less time and effort to enjoy. Additionally, movies are accessible to a broader audience, including young children and those with limited literacy skills. Finally, movies offer a shared experience that can bond friends and family and create lasting memories. While books offer a deeper ...
What's Better: the Book or the Movie?
Every book I've read has been better than the movie because it has more detail. Words help describe things better than just seeing them on the screen. In the book Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone, Harry, Hermione, and Ron play chess. The details let me imagine the huge chess set, the danger, the strategies.
Books Vs Movies
Books are always important in many aspects to have a sharp mind and be more creative. One needs to read good books. Regular reading of books is good for mental health and get to learn new things.
Books Versus Movies With English Teachers
Movies are easier to enjoy than books but, books give me more stimulation. Julien Gaumer: I enjoy both books and movies. However, if I were to compare both a book and a movie that was created from the book, then I would choose the book every time. ... Books are probably more educational depending on what it is. ...
The Book vs. the Movie: More Than Meets the Eye
The Book vs. the Movie: More Than Meets the Eye. Mar 17, 2021. ... Dawn holds a B.A. in English Education/Journalism from Lenoir-Rhyne University and an M.A. in English Education from Georgia State University. She has also earned National Board Certification and gifted endorsement. While teaching English at a public high school for 15 years ...
Are books better than films?
You can live as someone else, free of your own troubles, even if only for two hundred pages. Books are magic. Which is why I'm telling you all to forget about movie magic and get back to the pure ...
Books vs. Movies- Which is better in terms of education and
Reading is a more "active" process than passively watching a movie. More convenient to carry around. There is far more material available in book form than there is in movie form. Not every idea can be easily translated into an image or sound. Movies are often more sensationalized than books, so as to appeal to the "unwashed masses" who ...
Books or movies: which is better?
Books and movies are very different forms of entertainment, yet the two are compared often. Books require the reader to imagine the world and characters for themselves, while movies want the viewer to focus more on the visuals. However, for the sake of argument, it can be fun to debate which medium is better. Here I will be explaining why books ...
14 Educational Movies that Can Change the World
Educational Movies for Students. 1. Good Will Hunting. Year: 1997. Rated: R. Actors: Matt Damon, Robin Williams, Ben Affleck, Minnie Driver, Stellan Skarsgard. Genre: Drama. A janitor at M.I.T. is discovered to be a mathematical genius after solving a graduate-level equation nobody else has been able to.
Best Educational Movies, According to Teachers
Disney+. Coco is a delightful family movie that tells the story of one 12-year-old boy named Miguel and his larger-than-life adventure to the "Land of the Dead" to discover his ancestry. The ...
6 Advantages of Using Movies for Educational Purposes
Besides boosting students' academic abilities, movies also play a significant role in improving teachers' training skills and their way of handling different situations since most educational films feature common challenges that are faced in schools, such as: Rebellious youths. Underprivileged kids. Kids struggling with substance addictions.
Men Prefer Movies to Books
Men prefer to watch film adaptations of books rather than read the original, according to a new study. Researchers found the opposite is true for women. (BBC) Luckily, Nat Geo has great recommendations for both movies and books. These boys in Chennai, India, seem to prefer their media on a screen, not a page.
Why Generation Z Learners Prefer YouTube Lessons Over Printed Books
In a survey released last month of people ages 14 to 23—the so-called Generation Z group— YouTube ranked the highest as a preferred learning tool. Fifty-nine percent picked YouTube as a ...
Movies That Are Better Than the Book
The original books portray curiosity with a negative connotation, enforcing the "curiosity killed the cat" mentality. ~Ariane. The 39 Steps (1935) by John Buchan: Hitchcock's film is clearer and ...
10 Reasons Why Are Books Better Than Movies
There are a few reasons why movies are better than books. First, movies are visual. You can see the characters and the setting, and it's all in one place. With a book, you have to imagine everything yourself. Second, movies are more exciting. They have music and sound effects, and they move quickly.
14 Movies Better Than the Book: When To Ditch the Page for the Screen
Here are 14 films that are better than the books that inspired them. 1. The Princess Bride. This 1987 movie is a childhood favorite of the eighties. It captured the characterization so effectively, it's considered better than the book in breathing life to the love story between pirate Wesley and the bossy Buttercup.
Eight reasons why books are better than movies
3. Books provide a more pleasant journey. You know well that movies are time limited and can't present you the same exact book contents in just 2 hours. Well, while many like "up to the point ...
Speech on Why Books are Better Than Movies?
Books provide a richer understanding of the character's motivations and growth throughout the narrative. The reader has the flexibility to pause, reflect, and return to any part of the story, Books foster a more immersive and contemplative reading experience. Books are better than movies because you design the set the way you want it to look ...

Book vs. Movie: A Survey Settles the Debate Over Which Is Better

Related Articles

Books Vs Movies: Which Is Better? The Debate Settled!

Books vs Movies Pros and Cons

Pros of reading books over movies

Cons of reading books over movies

Pros of watching movies over reading books

Cons of watching movies over reading books

Why books are better than movies?

#1. Books nurture the reader’s imagination

#2. Books have more depth than movies

#3. Movie adaptations miss out on key points

#4. Reading has other benefits

#5. Books allow the reader to think more deeply

Why are movies better than books?

#1. Movies help bring hard-to-visualize scenes to life

#2. Acting is an art form

#3. Movies are quicker than books

#4. Social interactions are more relatable in movies

#5. You can watch a film with friends

Should Books Be Made Into Movies?

Books vs Movies: The Verdict

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

Find a blog post

Leave a Reply

Social media

Additional resources

IU Libraries

Watching, Not Reading

To Watch or to Read: The Great Debate of Books vs. Movies

Book Vs Movie: Compare And Contrast

The Advantages of Reading a Book Over Watching a Movie

The Advantages of Watching a Movie Over Reading a Book

The Importance of Originality: The Book vs. Movie Debate

The Impact of Film Adaptations on Book Sales

Comparing the Popularity of Books and Movies: A Statistical Analysis

Why Some Movies Fail to Capture the Essence of the Book

How Movies Can Enhance or Detract from the Reading Experience

Does Reading the Book First Ruin the Movie Experience?

The Role of Directors and Screenwriters in Adapting Books for Film

The Future of Books and Movies: Will One Outlast the Other?

Similar Posts

How To Telepathically Communicate With Someone

Can You Hit Dabs off Wax Paper: Important Thing You Need to Know

Are Reading Pillows Good for Your Back: Important Benefits of Reading Pillows

How to Wash Reading Pillow: Important Issues You Need to Know!

Book Page Holder: A Great Tool for Readers

Pen Vs Keyboard: Which is Better? Writing By Hand Vs Typing

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Books Versus Movies With English Teachers

Comments (0)

The Book vs. the Movie: More Than Meets the Eye

Why Novels and Films are So Different

Why Is Understanding Adaptation Important?

Discover Excelsior Classes

Are books better than films?

Your responses

Most viewed

Books vs. Movies- Which is better in terms of education and entertainment?

POPULAR STATES

CONNECT WITH US

Books or movies: which is better?

14 Educational Movies No Student Should Miss!

Educational Movies for Students

2. Freedom Wr iters

3. Race to Nowhere

4. Lean on Me

5. Theory of Ev erything

6. The So cial Network

7. Life of Pi

8. The B lind Side

9. Girls Ri sing

10. The Great Debaters

11. A Plasti c Ocean

12. Int o the Wild

13. T he Pursui t of Happyness

14. A B eautiful Mind

Final Thoughts

Related Articles

Bill & Ted’s Excellent Adventure